Are drawdown pensions safe? Not risk-free: the money stays invested and can fall in value, though some protections apply if a firm fails.

The honest answer has two halves. Drawdown carries investment risk, longevity risk and tax traps that nobody can remove. Separately, regulation and a compensation scheme cover what happens if a provider or adviser fails, or a scammer gets in the way.

Free guidance comes first. If you have a UK-based defined contribution pension, MoneyHelper says a Pension Wise appointment explains your options; it is free from age 50, or earlier in cases such as ill-health retirement. Sending the form on this page, to see how these risks sit with your pots and tax, means an FCA-authorised adviser calls you for nothing.

Is pension drawdown safe, and what is the main risk?

Drawdown is only as safe as the investments inside it, and it is not guaranteed. The FCA says investment-based income solutions such as drawdown "expose consumers to ongoing investment risk". The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) is equally plain about the limit of its own cover: it cannot accept claims "for poor investment performance", because "the nature of investments means their value can go down as well as up".

So the value of your pot can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than was paid in. Nothing in a drawdown plan promises an income level, and an offer of "guaranteed" returns on pension money deserves suspicion (see the scams section below). A lifetime annuity is the product designed to pay a set income; our annuity or drawdown comparison and annuity guide cover that trade-off, and switching later is its own question.

Falling markets, badly timed withdrawals and charges

Pots lose value when markets fall, and income taken at the wrong moment can make a fall harder to recover from. In its review of retirement income advice, the FCA notes that "the timing of encashments can impact sustainability if withdrawals are made when investment fund values have dropped (sequencing risk)". Charges also come out of the pot; pension charges explains what to look for.

Cash has its own rules. The FCA's current drawdown rules, COBS 19.10 in its Handbook, include cash warnings, one of which applies where a request would leave more than 50% of a drawdown fund in cash-like investments. Going into drawdown without advice, you are first asked by the provider whether to use investment pathways, choose your own investments or, where that applies, keep your current ones. Pathways are ready-made choices matched to your plans for the next five years, not a promise of any result; our drawdown guide covers the basics.

Can drawdown income run out before you do?

Yes. That is longevity risk: the pot can be used up while you are still alive, because drawdown has no built-in end date for the income. The FCA points out that objectives differ: some people need income to last for life, while others "want to take more, or possibly all, available income to meet a specific objective in earlier years".

Weighing it up means looking at pot size, the amount taken, investment returns, charges, how long you may live and what other income you have. How much to take from drawdown sets out what decides whether an amount lasts.

Tax on withdrawals and the money purchase annual allowance

GOV.UK says "You’ll usually pay tax on income from your pensions", with the amount depending on your total income during the tax year. Taking money out of a pension has the wider picture.

Starting to take income also changes what you can pay in later. On GOV.UK, flexibly accessing a pension, such as drawing income from a flexi-access drawdown fund or taking an uncrystallised lump sum, can lower your annual allowance to what it calls the money purchase annual allowance. HMRC’s Pensions Tax Manual says the trigger occurs immediately before the first payment from a newly designated flexi-access drawdown fund. A lifetime annuity can trigger it too, if you became entitled to it from 6 April 2015 and its contract permits lower payments other than in circumstances the rules prescribe. HMRC puts the money purchase annual allowance at £10,000 for tax year 2023-24 onwards, and our MPAA guide explains how it works. Whether taking only the tax-free cash sets it off is covered in setting up drawdown. Before taking a first withdrawal, ask an adviser about the trigger and your contribution plans; leave your details and a free call-back can follow.

What protects your drawdown pension if a firm fails?

The FSCS can step in when a UK-regulated pension provider, SIPP operator or adviser has gone out of business. Its pensions page sets the limits by date. "If the firm failed after 1 April 2019", it can normally pay 100% of a claim with no upper limit where it was your pension provider (generally a UK-regulated insurer providing a contract of long-term insurance), but "if your pension provider was a SIPP operator" it can pay up to £85,000 per eligible person, per firm. The same £85,000 limit applies where a failed firm gave you bad pension advice. It adds that SIPPs are typically treated as ‘uninsured’ pension schemes, so they are not covered in the same way as insurer-provided pensions.

Cover also reaches investments. Where an investment held in a SIPP or similar personal pension fails and its UK-regulated provider fails, the FSCS "may be able to pay compensation up to £85,000 per pension scheme member". More broadly it may protect you if a provider goes out of business and there is a shortfall in the money or assets it holds for you. It "can’t protect Occupational Pension Schemes (OPS) if they fail"; the Pension Protection Fund may do so.

Cover applies only where the PRA or FCA has authorised the firm and regulated the service, so check the FCA Register first. If you are weighing a SIPP provider or comparing drawdown providers, ask each to confirm how your money is held and whether it is FSCS protected.

How to spot drawdown and pension scams

The FCA’s list of warning signs includes promises of a guaranteed better return, high-pressure selling, unusual investments and several firms each taking a fee. Its advice on cold calls is blunt: "If you get a call out of the blue (a cold call) about your pension, the safest thing to do is hang up". An unexpected offer of a free review, it says, is "likely to be a scam", and anyone drawn into an early-release scheme could be taxed at 55% on the amount taken out.

The FCA advises checking that any adviser is authorised by it, and never taking advice from the company that contacted you. Our pension scams guide goes through what to do next, and you can report a suspected scam on the FCA pension scams page.

Drawdown risk: your other questions answered

Why is my drawdown pension losing money?

Usually because the investments inside it have fallen, because withdrawals and charges together exceed growth, or both. What to do depends on your plans and the rest of your income, so this is a point for guidance or an adviser rather than a rule of thumb.

Is a drawdown pension protected if my provider goes bust?

Often, depending on the type of provider and when it failed. The limits in the FSCS section above show the pattern; your provider can say how your money is held and whether it is FSCS protected.

What growth rate can I expect from drawdown?

None can be promised, because growth depends on what the pot is invested in. Treat any firm quoting a fixed rate for drawdown with care.

What warnings come before I start drawdown?

Without advice, the provider must first ask how you want to choose your investments, with investment pathways as one option, and the FCA's rules add a cash warning where a request would put more than half the fund in cash-like investments. Pension Wise appointments are free, and MoneyHelper says an appointment explains your options.

Can I still choose the older capped drawdown?

Not for a new fund. According to HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual, capped drawdown funds could no longer be opened from 6 April 2015, though some opened by 5 April 2015 carry on. Flexi-access versus capped drawdown sets out the difference.

Each of these risks looks different once your pots, tax and plans are counted, and an FCA-authorised adviser will count them for nothing once the enquiry form is sent.