Police ill health retirement is decided by your force on a doctor's opinion, and the pension depends on the 1987, 2006 or 2015 scheme.

Who decides on ill health retirement for police officers?

The force's Police Pension Authority decides, not the doctor and not you. The Home Office's 2015 members' guide says the authority "has discretion to retire a member on medical grounds", and it can only get there after putting set questions to a Selected Medical Practitioner (SMP), a doctor it chooses. You are given a copy of the SMP's report.

Medical retirement can reshape a household's income for good, so a serving or former officer might like an FCA-authorised adviser to talk the pension side over; for a free ring-back on your own case, complete the form on this page.

A serving officer can contact their staff association for advice, and the guide names the National Association of Retired Police Officers (NARPO) for retired officers in a dispute.

This page covers the England and Wales schemes as the Home Office guides describe them. Since 1 April 2022 every serving officer has been in the 2015 scheme, and the 1987 and 2006 rules apply to service built up in them. The guides date from November 2017, so your force's own figures are the answer. Ill health retirement across all UK pensions, including the HMRC test, is on the UK overview.

What does the Selected Medical Practitioner decide?

In the 2015 scheme the authority must put four questions: are you unfit for ordinary police duties, is that likely to be permanent, are you also unfit for any regular job outside the force, and is that likely to be permanent. Regular employment means an annual average of at least 30 hours a week.

The doctor looks at practical abilities such as walking, restraint, writing and decision-making. In the 2015 guide a condition is permanent if likely to continue until normal pension age or death, whichever is sooner, assuming appropriate treatment, though not treatment the authority accepts you could reasonably refuse.

Being found unfit does not settle it. The guide says: "Even if an SMP determines that you are permanently medically unfit, it does not automatically follow that you will be granted ill-health retirement." The authority also looks at alternative duties you could do and still stay in the service.

Two more conditions apply in the 2015 scheme. Qualifying service of two years is needed, though not where an injury in the execution of duty, received without your own default, caused the unfitness. And if the authority ruled at joining, after a medical, that you were ineligible for ill-health benefits, no ill-health pension is payable. With under two years' service, a refund of contributions is payable instead.

Police ill health retirement in the 2015 scheme: lower and upper tier

The 2015 scheme has two tiers, and the second is paid on top of the first. The lower tier is for an officer permanently unfit for police duties but not for all regular work. The guide says it is "calculated in the same way as a retirement pension payable at NPA, but without subtracting the early payment reduction", and that your accrued pension is not enhanced. It is paid at once, and part can be commuted for a lump sum limited to 25% of the value of the member’s pension.

The enhanced upper tier is for an officer who is also permanently unfit for any regular employment. It compensates for the lost chance of working until normal pension age. With under five years' aggregate service, the top-up is limited to the lesser of three times the accrued pension and a formula based on final pay and the service you would have had to normal pension age. From five years, the formula alone applies, and part-time service reduces the enhancement proportionately.

Both tiers rise in line with CPI while paid. The whole ill-health pension "may be reduced by up to a half" if you substantially contributed to your unfitness by your own default. Officers with 1987 or 2006 service, not yet at normal pension age, get a pension reflecting those schemes too. The McCloud remedy page explains which scheme your years sit in, and how a police pension is built shows the ordinary calculation.

The 1987 scheme: the ill-health pension and gratuity

The 1987 scheme pays an immediate pension and lump sum at any age. The police authority has discretion to retire an officer permanently disabled for ordinary police duties. You need two years' pensionable service, or any length of service if the disablement results from an injury on duty.

The pension is "calculated in a similar way to an ordinary pension and is then normally enhanced to compensate for the lost opportunity of serving until normal retirement". The guide's table adds nothing from two to five years' service (1/60 a year), counts 2/60 a year from five to ten years, gives 20/60 from ten to 13, and above 13 gives 7/60 plus 1/60 a year to 20 years and 2/60 beyond. The maximum is 40/60ths within compulsory retirement age, and an injury on duty carries a minimum of 1/60. Up to a quarter of the pension can be commuted for a lump sum; the commutation factors page covers ordinary pensions. Under two years' pensionable service, with no injury on duty, a gratuity equal to your contributions is paid instead.

The 2006 scheme: standard pension and enhanced top-up

The 2006 scheme also has two levels, named differently. A standard ill-health pension and lump sum go to an officer permanently disabled for ordinary police duties but not for every regular job. They are "calculated in a similar way to an ordinary pension", using pay and service when you became disabled, and are not enhanced. The two-year rule applies, waived for an injury on duty received without your own default; below two years a taxable gratuity of at least your contributions is paid.

If you are also permanently disabled for any regular employment, an enhanced top-up is added. With under five years of service, actual service is multiplied by four, subject to the enhancement not exceeding half the prospective service. From five years, half the prospective service to 35 years' service or age 55, whichever is earlier, is added. Part-time service reduces the enhancement.

Service spread over two or three police schemes is awkward to untangle alone, so this page's short form can bring you an adviser's call at no cost.

Are police injury awards part of ill health retirement?

No. Injury awards come from a separate scheme. The 2015 guide says injury benefit is payable if an injury on duty leaves you permanently unfit for ordinary police duties and you have left the service, and that "this benefit is separate from those provided under the 2015 Scheme". The 1987 guide says its award, under the Police (Injury Benefit) Regulations 2006, "does not form part of the pension scheme".

How each is taxed is on the police pension tax page, and the general rules are on the ill health pension tax page.

Can a police ill-health pension be reviewed or stopped?

Yes, in some circumstances. Reviews are at the authority's discretion, with an SMP's report. In the 2015 scheme, a lower-tier pension alone can be reviewed before normal pension age, "at any time the Police Pension Authority chooses". If the SMP finds you are no longer unfit for ordinary police duties, the pension stops and the authority may give you notice to rejoin at a rank no lower than before. With both tiers, reviews before State Pension age are at intervals of no less than five years, and if you are found fit for regular employment only the upper tier goes. If a lower-tier condition worsens within five years you may be reassessed for the upper tier; the guide says that limit does not apply to a progressive condition.

In the 1987 scheme, a review can happen up to the point you would have had 25 years' pensionable service or reached compulsory retirement age, and "once you have reached the age at which you could have retired, your ill-health pension cannot be cancelled". In the 2006 scheme, the standard pension cannot be cancelled after that age, though the top-up could be. In both older schemes, declining an offer to rejoin turns the pension into a deferred one, not back in payment until you are 60 in the 1987 scheme or 65 in the 2006 scheme.

How do you appeal a police ill-health decision?

You appeal to a Police Medical Appeal Board, and the clock is short. Under the 2015 guide you must normally give notice to the Police Pension Authority within 28 days of receiving the SMP's report. Before it goes to the board, you and the authority can agree to send the matter back to the SMP under the internal review procedure. The board's decision is final, subject to review by the courts or, if you and the authority both agree, reconsideration by the board.

The older guides call it a Medical Appeal Board, with the same 28 days. All three guides send some other award decisions to the Crown Court; the older two allow 21 days. In the 2015 scheme the Pensions Ombudsman cannot investigate a complaint where a medical appeal has begun.

Police Scotland and PSNI officers: their own ill health rules

Each country runs its own arrangements. In Scotland the Scottish Public Pensions Agency (SPPA) describes a standard ill health pension, for an officer permanently unable to carry out police duties but able to take other work, and an enhanced top-up for one unable to do any regular job. Payment "can only be made following an assessment by Police Scotland’s independent medical adviser". Scottish injury awards come under the Police (Injury Benefit) (Scotland) Regulations 2007, with the Scottish Police Authority making the final decision. More is on the Scottish police pension page.

Northern Ireland has its own 2015 scheme, with a members' guide on the PSNI website to use instead of these ones.

More questions about police ill health retirement

How much is a police ill health pension?

It depends on scheme, pay and service. In the 2015 guide's own example, an officer of 35 with seven years' service on £35,000 a year has a £5,000 accrued pension and a £7,911 upper tier, £12,911 a year in all, an illustration rather than today's pay.

Can I work out a police ill health pension myself?

A real figure needs your final pay, service and scheme, so ask your force's pensions administrator; the 2015 guide points to a GOV.UK list of their contacts.

How long until a decision on police medical retirement?

Timing depends on the medical examination, the SMP's report and the authority's decision; your force's pensions team can say where a case stands. Your own deadline is the appeal: normally 28 days from receiving the SMP's report.

Can I get ill health retirement after leaving the force?

Possibly. A deferred pension can be paid early, without the actuarial reduction, to a member of the 2015 scheme who is later found permanently unfit for all regular work; the 2006 scheme is similar, but a member dismissed or required to resign under the Conduct Regulations depends on the authority's discretion.

What about police staff?

These schemes are for police officers. A staff member's pension depends on the employer, so ask the pensions administrator; if it is the Local Government Pension Scheme, see the LGPS ill health page.

Retiring early with a reduction is covered on the early retirement page and the pension age page, and the Universal Credit page covers the benefits side. Before you choose between medical retirement, staying on and claiming benefits, this page's short form can bring you a free chat with an adviser.

Sources