Should you use your ISA or pension first? No order suits everyone: it turns on tax in each year, the allowances left and what you leave behind.
Pension Wise, the free guidance MoneyHelper offers on defined contribution pensions, is impartial and backed by government, and is a sensible first stop before you start drawing money. Pots, bands and an estate all pull on one another, and fitting them together for your situation falls to an FCA-authorised adviser. Where you want that, nothing is charged for the call, which comes after you have filled out the form on this page. Below are the factors, with illustrative principles rather than advice on your own money.
Should you draw from your ISA or your pension first?
Four things decide it: how each withdrawal is taxed, how your tax-free allowances fall in each tax year, whether taking a pension flexibly limits later pension saving, and what happens to each pot on death. As income changes, the pot you start with need not be the one you finish with. Investments in either can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in.
Choosing where to save while working is a separate question, in pension or ISA?; how much to take out each year is in drawdown withdrawal rates, and how drawdown works in pension drawdown.
How is a withdrawal from each one taxed?
Inside an ISA, interest, income and capital gains are free of tax, and none of it goes on a tax return. Money can come out at any time with the tax benefits intact, though the ISA's own terms may carry rules or charges, and a Lifetime ISA has different withdrawal rules. A withdrawal therefore creates no tax bill of its own.
A pension works differently. Under HMRC's rules the tax-free portion is normally 25% of the value built up, with £268,275 the most that can be taken; a protected allowance may raise that ceiling. That lump sum leaves your Personal Allowance untouched. Tax comes off the remainder before it reaches you, and the remainder joins the rest of your taxable income: State Pension, earnings, rent and savings interest all sit in one total. The lump sum is explained in taking the tax-free lump sum, and the rest in tax on drawdown.
The current tax year runs from 6 April 2026 to 5 April 2027, and the standard Personal Allowance is £12,570. Above it, outside Scotland, the basic rate of 20% covers £12,571 to £50,270, the higher rate of 40% £50,271 to £125,140, and the additional rate of 45% anything over that. Scotland's bands differ.
How do each year's allowances change the order?
Both pots work in tax years, and each year's allowance is separate. Three illustrations show how the rules interact, not what to do.
- The Personal Allowance. Total annual income below it is not usually taxed. Where other income leaves room under £12,570, pension income up to that level is not usually taxed, so a year drawing only from an ISA could leave that room unused.
- Band edges. A big pension withdrawal can mean tax at a higher rate and a further bill at the end of the year, GOV.UK warns. Someone whose withdrawal would cross a band may weigh smaller sums over several years, or an ISA top-up in the year it would cross.
- The ISA allowance. The £20,000 limit applies each tax year to what you pay in, across all your ISAs together. Money you leave in keeps its tax-free basis, and only a flexible ISA lets you replace cash taken out in the same year without using more allowance.
What does taking a pension flexibly do to the annual allowance?
ISA withdrawals never carry this cost. The annual allowance is £60,000 in this tax year, but HMRC's rules can cut what you may pay into your pensions once you flexibly access one, such as by drawing drawdown income or taking an uncrystallised funds pension lump sum. The reduced limit is called the money purchase annual allowance, and from tax year 2023-24 it stands at £10,000.
Once triggered, HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual says, it applies for that tax year and each later one. Neither a pension commencement lump sum nor a trivial commutation lump sum sets it off, and nor does a lifetime annuity that cannot decrease other than in prescribed circumstances. A lifetime annuity starting on or after 6 April 2015 whose terms let payments fall, other than in prescribed circumstances, does set it off, so the type matters. Fuller detail is in the money purchase annual allowance guide.
For someone who has stopped paying into pensions this may count for little. For anyone still earning, or with an employer still paying in, it is worth weighing before the pension goes first. Whether that ceiling would catch your plans depends on timing and method, and an adviser can examine your case on a no-fee call arranged by this page's short form.
Does inheritance tax on unused pensions change the order?
This is settled law rather than a plan. The Finance Act 2026 (2026 c. 11) received Royal Assent on 18 March 2026. Its section 66 inserts a new section into IHTA 1984, the Inheritance Tax Act: a member of a registered pension scheme, a qualifying non-UK pension scheme or a section 615(3) scheme is treated as holding "notional pension property" just before death. Broadly, that is pot money that may or must fund benefits on death in a money purchase arrangement, and lump sum death benefits in a defined benefits one. Left out, among others, is anything that can be paid only as a dependants' scheme pension, only as a dependants' or nominees' annuity purchased with the member's own lifetime annuity, or only because the member died while in particular employment or work. Section 71 sets the start: anyone dying on 6 April 2027 or later.
ISA investments already form part of the estate for Inheritance Tax, so for a death on or after that date an unused pension pot and an ISA can enter the same calculation.
Income tax on what a beneficiary receives from a pension is a separate question, covered in tax on an inherited pension, and the detail of the new rule is in pensions and inheritance tax.
Which person might weigh what
These are patterns, and none is a recommendation.
- A person with little other income may find the Personal Allowance and the 25% tax-free cash do most of the work early on.
- A person with a large pension may find the tax bands, more than the choice of pot, decide how much to take out.
- A person still adding to a pension may treat the money purchase annual allowance as a reason to be careful with flexible access.
- A person thinking about an estate may weigh who receives each pot and how they are taxed, since for deaths on or after 6 April 2027 both can count towards the estate.
Your other pots, State Pension and family all feed in as well. To weigh ISA-first against pension-first with your own numbers, fill the form on this page; soon after, an FCA-authorised adviser rings, fee-free.
Tax-free cash, State Pension, Scotland and ISA limits
Can the tax-free cash be taken a bit at a time?
Often. Smaller cash sums are among the ways GOV.UK lists for drawing on a defined contribution pot, and HMRC's worked example has an uncrystallised funds pension lump sum paid a quarter tax free, three quarters taxable as pension income. Providers decide which methods they offer, and this one triggers the lower allowance above; more on UFPLS.
Does the State Pension count when working out tax on my pension?
Yes. Basic or new, it is listed among the income making up your total taxable income. See whether the State Pension is taxable.
Do Scottish taxpayers use the same income tax bands?
No. Residents of Scotland have their own bands, so the rates above are for the rest of the UK; check the Scottish ones on GOV.UK.
Must ISA money be declared if I file a return?
No. Anyone completing a return does not need to declare ISA interest, income or capital gains.
Does withdrawing from an ISA use up my allowance?
Not by itself, because the allowance covers money paid in. With a flexible ISA, cash you took out can go back in the same tax year without reducing that year's allowance; with one that is not flexible it cannot.
Sources
- GOV.UK, ISAs: how ISAs work (read 2 November 2026), withdrawing your money (read 3 November), if you die (read 29 October)
- GOV.UK, Tax when you get a pension (taxed and tax-free pages), read 26 October 2026
- GOV.UK, the Income Tax rates page, read 26 October 2026
- GOV.UK, Annual allowance, read 3 November 2026
- HMRC Pensions Tax Manual, PTM056510, PTM056520 and PTM056530, read 26 and 27 October 2026
- legislation.gov.uk, Finance Act 2026, section 66 (read 27 October 2026) and section 71 (read 2 November 2026)
- MoneyHelper, Pension Wise, read 26 October 2026