Research · for choirs, arts groups & u3a groups

Singing, Arts and Loneliness in Later Life: What the Trials Measured

Published 2026-11-15

The best-tested evidence that singing together can ease loneliness in later life comes from one large US trial, where older people in senior-centre choirs became less lonely than those still waiting to join. Other arts trials mostly measured mood, wellbeing or quality of life instead, and most are small and short.

Choirs, singing clubs, dance classes, craft circles and trips to the theatre are already a large part of how older people spend time together, and many are run by older people themselves. Funders and health services increasingly ask whether such groups do anything for loneliness. The research answer is encouraging in places, uncertain in others, and depends on what each study actually measured.

390adults aged 60 and over at 12 US senior centres took part in the Community of Voices trial, where choir members’ loneliness improved more than that of a wait-list group (standardised effect size 0.34)[1]
258people aged 60 and over in East Kent, England, joined the Silver Song Clubs trial, which measured mental health-related quality of life, anxiety and depression, not loneliness[2]

One large choir trial found loneliness fell; the best-known UK trial measured mental health

Community of Voices, run at US senior centres, is the largest randomised trial we found of a community choir that measured loneliness in later life. Twelve senior centres funded through the US Administration on Aging were randomly split: half started a choir straight away, the other half joined a wait-list and began six months later. Of the 390 community-dwelling adults aged 60 and over who took part, the average age was 71.3 and 65% were from non-white backgrounds. Six months on, 92% were still in the study[1].

Choirs met weekly for 90 minutes, led by community music professionals; the main comparison came after 23 sessions. People attended a median of 19 of those 23 sessions, and 73% came to at least half[1]. Loneliness was measured with a questionnaire from the NIH Toolbox, a US set of standard health measures, alongside sadness and anxiety. Compared with the wait-list group, choir members had significantly greater improvements in loneliness (standardised effect size 0.34) and in interest in life (0.39). There were no significant differences in cognitive or physical outcomes, or in health care costs[1].

Some cautions come with the result. In an earlier report of the same results, the team noted that two of six psychosocial outcomes improved[3], and people knew whether their centre had a choir yet, which can colour self-reported answers. The paper’s results table also flags that the two groups differed in loneliness at the start, with the choir group somewhat lonelier, so part of the gap closing may reflect that. And 76% of participants were women, which the authors note is typical of choir studies[1], so the result says less about older men.

Silver Song Clubs, England

The Silver Song Clubs trial is often cited on singing and loneliness, but it did not measure loneliness. It was a pilot pragmatic randomised trial comparing group singing with usual activities among 258 people aged 60 or over across five centres. Its outcome was mental health-related quality of life on the SF-12 health survey. At six months the singing group scored higher (mean difference 2.35 points; 95% confidence interval 0.06 to 4.76), and at three months it also showed less anxiety and depression. The authors judged singing marginally more cost-effective than usual activities[2]. That is a real finding about mood and quality of life, not about loneliness.

Other singing trials found gains in mood and wellbeing, with loneliness less clear

  • Sing4Health. A randomised trial offered a 34-session singing programme to day-care centre users (average age 76.66) with low average education and income: 89 sang, 60 were on an active wait-list. Loneliness was among the outcomes. The programme had significant effects on positive mood and on social wellbeing, sustained at follow-up. The abstract reports no direct effect on loneliness, only an indirect link through feeling part of the group[4].
  • Choral singing with an active comparison. In a two-year trial, 200 community-dwelling older people at risk of cognitive decline were randomised to weekly one-hour choral singing or a health education programme with the same group format. The outcomes reported were positive screens for depression and anxiety. Both groups did similarly well; the authors note that earlier trials comparing singing with no activity reported positive results[5]. Loneliness was not among the outcomes in the abstract.
  • Online singing for older people with HIV, US. Researchers including the Community of Voices lead author adapted a group-singing programme into United Voices, a 12-week online and in-person programme[6]. A pilot that randomised 23 people with HIV aged 50 and over tested whether such a trial was feasible, not whether loneliness fell, and is a preprint not yet peer reviewed[7].

So the claim that singing reduces loneliness rests largely on one well-run US trial; trials of mood and wellbeing are more numerous.

Going to museums and galleries is linked with lower loneliness in England, though that is not proof

Going to see art, film, theatre or music is another kind of arts engagement, which researchers call receptive engagement. The English Longitudinal Study of Ageing (ELSA), which follows a national sample of people aged 50 and over in England, lets researchers test whether it goes with less loneliness over time.

Using ELSA waves from 2004–05 and 2014–15, one analysis looked at 6,222 people at one point in time and 3,127 followed over the decade. Loneliness was measured with the three-item short form of the Revised UCLA Loneliness Scale, with a score of 6 or more counted as lonely. At one point in time, more frequent visits to the cinema, museums, galleries, theatre, concerts or opera went with lower odds of loneliness. Followed over time, and after adjusting for a wide range of social, economic, health and community factors, people who visited museums, galleries or exhibitions every few months or more had lower odds of later loneliness than those who never went (odds ratio 0.68; 95% confidence interval 0.48 to 0.95). The evidence for theatre, concerts and opera was weaker[8].

This is an association. Gallery-goers may differ in health, money and transport to begin with, and adjustment reduces that bias without removing it; the study cannot show that a gallery visit prevents loneliness.

Who gets to go: cultural attendance is far lower at older ages

It also matters who gets to go at all. Among the 13 EU countries charted below, in 2022 the share of people aged 65 and over who went even once in the year to the cinema, a live performance or a cultural site ranged from 65.8% in Denmark to 6.2% in Romania[9].

People aged 65+ who went to the cinema, a live performance or a cultural site in the past year, 2022Horizontal bar chart of the share of people aged 65 and over who attended at least one cultural activity (cinema, live performance or cultural site) in the previous 12 months, 2022: Denmark 65.8%, Netherlands 50.8%, Sweden 47.6%, Finland 45.9%, Spain 35.2%, France 33.8%, Ireland 32.3%, Portugal 25.5%, Poland 24.6%, Italy 15.4%, Greece 14.5%, Bulgaria 7.0%, Romania 6.2%.0%20%40%60%80%100%Denmark65.8%Netherlands50.8%Sweden47.6%Finland45.9%Spain35.2%France33.8%Ireland32.3%Portugal25.5%Poland24.6%Italy15.4%Greece14.5%Bulgaria7.0%Romania6.2%
Share of people aged 65 and over, living in private households, who went at least once in the previous 12 months to the cinema, a live performance (theatre, concerts, ballet) or a cultural site (historical monuments, museums, art galleries or archaeological sites). Selected countries; 2022 EU survey module. This measures going to arts events, not taking part in a choir or class, and says nothing about loneliness. Source: Eurostat, ilc_scp03, data accessed November 2026.

In every country with 2022 data, fewer people aged 75 and over had been than people aged 16–24. In Italy, 67.5% of people aged 16–24 had been to at least one cultural activity in the year, against 9.2% of those aged 75 and over; in Spain the figures were 82.3% and 24.9%[9]. These are snapshots of different generations in one year, not the same people ageing, and the gaps track health, income, mobility and how near venues are.

Cultural attendance in the past year: ages 16-24 compared with 75+, 2022Paired bar chart of the share who attended at least one cultural activity in the previous 12 months, 2022, ages 16-24 versus 75 and over: Denmark 88.2% vs 60.5%, Netherlands 86.5% vs 43.5%, Spain 82.3% vs 24.9%, France 78.9% vs 24.7%, Poland 83.1% vs 17.3%, Italy 67.5% vs 9.2%.Aged 16-24Aged 75+0%20%40%60%80%100%Denmark88.2%60.5%Netherlands86.5%43.5%Spain82.3%24.9%France78.9%24.7%Poland83.1%17.3%Italy67.5%9.2%
Went at least once in the previous 12 months to the cinema, a live performance or a cultural site, by age group, 2022. These are different people at different ages in one year, not the same people followed over time, so the gap reflects health, income, transport and generation as well as age. Private households only, so people in care homes are not counted. Source: Eurostat, ilc_scp03, data accessed November 2026.

Dance, crafts and visual arts: small trials with short follow-up

In a randomised trial of 48 people aged 65 and over registered at a family health centre, 16 were assigned to dance movement therapy, 16 to a walking programme and 16 to no intervention, with the two active groups meeting twice a week for a total of six sessions. Loneliness was measured with the Loneliness Scale for the Elderly, which separates emotional from social loneliness. Both the dance and the walking groups improved on emotional and social loneliness compared with the control group, and dance did somewhat better than walking on the overall loneliness score[10]. With 16 people per group and no long-term follow-up, this is an early signal.

In Guangxi, China, an eight-week programme combining Zhuang embroidery, cultural storytelling and group exchange was tested with 80 Zhuang adults aged 55–65 around the time of retirement, allocated by community to the programme or a wait-list. The main outcome was psychological wellbeing, which improved more in the programme group immediately afterwards. Loneliness was a secondary outcome and showed short-term favourable movement, but the difference had faded by follow-up[11]. Allocation was not random, a weaker design than a trial.

Both mixed the art form with regular group contact, so it is hard to separate the effect of the dancing or needlework from meeting others each week; the walking group improved too.

Reviews agree the arts show promise, and that the evidence is weak

The most-cited overview, a 2019 scoping review for WHO Europe, drew on more than 3,000 studies and concluded that the arts have a major role in preventing ill health, promoting health and managing illness across the lifespan. Its evidence ranged from uncontrolled pilot studies and case studies to national cohorts and randomised trials[12]. It maps a large field rather than pooling any effect on loneliness.

Reviews that grade quality are more cautious. A 2026 umbrella review of participatory arts for older people without dementia found 18 systematic reviews, 12 of them rated low or critically low quality on the AMSTAR 2 checklist. In the six moderate-to-high quality reviews, dance was the most studied art form and was linked to better physical wellbeing; for other art forms and other kinds of wellbeing, results were mixed[13].

Pooled figures need care. A 2026 network meta-analysis of 45 trials of loneliness interventions for older people reported a very large standardised effect for music therapy (−2.94), but rated the certainty of every comparison as very low and concluded that not enough evidence had yet accumulated to answer its question[14]. A meta-analysis of 26 trials of social prescribing for people aged 60 and over found that arts-based activities had the largest effects on both quality of life and loneliness of the types it compared[15]. A 2026 narrative review of cultural prescribing concluded that referral-based arts programmes may reduce loneliness and isolation, but the evidence is limited by observational designs, varied programmes, selective participation and too little long-term and economic evaluation[16].

For how arts fit among other approaches, see our overview of what reduces loneliness in later life, our study of social prescribing and our study of group exercise and walking groups.

What the evidence asks of us

The evidence does not support promising that a choir or art class will end anyone’s loneliness. It does support funding community arts, and their evaluation, as part of how places help older people stay connected.

  • Fund the groups to last. After the Community of Voices trial ended, the choirs continued; the team found that facilitators far outweighed barriers, but that health and access problems held some people back, and transport and funding were barriers for the organisations[17].
  • Pay for access, not just activity. Cultural attendance among people aged 75 and over is far lower than among younger adults in every country charted above[9]. Transport, affordable tickets and sessions where older people already go are part of the intervention.
  • Build in trusted relationships and support for artists. The cultural prescribing review found that programmes depend on trusted relationships, accessible and sustainable cultural infrastructure, support for artists and community organisations, and attention to who does and does not take part[16].
  • Reach beyond the usual participants. Most choir trial participants have been women[1], and in the ELSA analysis people who went to galleries differed from those who did not in ways that had to be adjusted for[8]. Programmes designed with older men and people on low incomes are where new evidence is most needed.
  • Measure loneliness properly. Funders should ask for controlled designs, a named loneliness scale, an active comparison group where possible, and follow-up after the programme ends. The choral singing trial with a matched comparison shows why: compared with another weekly group, singing did as well, not better[5].

WHO Europe’s review called for promoting arts engagement at individual, local and national levels and for collaboration across sectors[12]. More is in the Loneliness in Later Life library.

Language: this piece says "older people" and treats loneliness as a common human experience that anyone can have, not a personal failing or an illness. It keeps apart three things that are often mixed up: loneliness (how people feel about their relationships), social isolation (how few social contacts they have) and living alone (a household arrangement). Where a study uses another term, such as "seniors" or "older adults", we keep it when quoting that study.

Why we're publishing this

Choirs, arts groups and u3a interest groups are very often run by older people for each other. They are often asked to prove their worth to funders. We set out what the studies found, in their own terms, so groups can make their case accurately: where loneliness fell, where mood or wellbeing was measured instead, and where evidence is thin. The case for these groups belongs to the people who run them and take part.

How to read this data

Community of Voices was a cluster randomised trial in the US that measured loneliness with an NIH Toolbox questionnaire; Silver Song Clubs was a randomised trial in England that measured mental health-related quality of life, anxiety and depression, not loneliness. The ELSA analysis is an observational cohort that counted people as lonely if they scored 6 or more on the three-item UCLA scale; it shows an association, not cause and effect. Effect sizes from different scales and designs are not directly comparable, and none of these figures is a loneliness rate.

The Eurostat charts measure attendance at arts events in a 2022 European survey module, not taking part in a choir or class, and say nothing about loneliness; they compare age groups in one year rather than following people. Most trials ran for weeks or months with little follow-up, most participants were women, and many recruited people already willing to join a group. We found many more studies of mood and wellbeing than of loneliness itself, and few from outside Europe, North America and East Asia.

Use this data

Free to cite with attribution to Understanding Aging. u3a groups, choirs and arts groups, senior centres, lunch clubs, befriending services, charities, campaigners and journalists are welcome to reuse these figures and charts. For the underlying figures as a spreadsheet, get in touch.

Suggested citation: Understanding Aging (2026). Singing, Arts and Loneliness in Later Life: What the Trials Measured. https://understandingaging.org/research/arts-singing-older-people

Important: This article summarises published research and statistics for general information. It is not medical or care advice and cannot be used to diagnose, treat or predict anything about an individual. If loneliness, low mood or isolation is affecting your health or someone else’s, a doctor or another health professional can help, and local services for older people can often put you in touch with groups and support nearby.

Sources

  1. Johnson JK, Stewart AL, Acree M, et al. A community choir intervention to promote well-being among diverse older adults: results from the Community of Voices trial. Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 2020. academic.oup.com/psychsocgerontology/article/75/3/549/5162497
  2. Coulton S, Clift S, Skingley A, Rodriguez J. Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of community singing on mental health-related quality of life of older people: randomised controlled trial. British Journal of Psychiatry, 2015. europepmc.org/article/MED/26089304
  3. Johnson JK, et al. A choir intervention to promote well-being among diverse older adults: the Community of Voices trial (conference abstract). Innovation in Aging, 2018. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC6228074
  4. Galinha IC, García-Martín MÁ, Lima ML. Sing4Health: randomised controlled trial of the effects of a singing group program on the subjective and social well-being of older adults. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being, 2022. europepmc.org/article/MED/34378330
  5. Ng TKS, Lim ZH, Todd M, et al. Effects of choral singing on depression and anxiety in older adults: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 2025. europepmc.org/article/MED/40449223
  6. Hill M, Greene M, Johnson JK, Tan JY. United Voices group-singing intervention to address loneliness and social isolation among older people with HIV during the COVID-19 pandemic: intervention adaption study. JMIR Formative Research, 2024. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC11496909
  7. Tan JY, Bouguettaya A, Reeves K, et al. The social cure effects of United Voices: a randomized waitlist-controlled pilot trial of an online group-singing intervention for older people with HIV (preprint, not peer reviewed). Preprints.org, 2026. doi.org/10.20944/preprints202608.0274.v1
  8. Tymoszuk U, Perkins R, Fancourt D, Williamon A. Cross-sectional and longitudinal associations between receptive arts engagement and loneliness among older adults. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 2020. europepmc.org/article/MED/31511928
  9. Eurostat. Persons participating in cultural or sport activities in the last 12 months by sex, age, educational attainment, activity type and frequency (ilc_scp03), 2022 data. Eurostat, 2026. ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/ilc_scp03
  10. Das Gecim GY, Ustun G. The effect of dance movement therapy and walking interventions on loneliness and self-neglect in older people aged 65 and over: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Geriatrics, 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12911147
  11. Li J, Xiang J. A culturally tailored Zhuang embroidery intervention for psychological well-being among Zhuang adults in the retirement transition in Guangxi: a waitlist-controlled quasi-experimental study. Frontiers in Public Health, 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13626903
  12. Fancourt D, Finn S. What is the evidence on the role of the arts in improving health and well-being? A scoping review. Health Evidence Network synthesis report 67. WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2019. who.int/europe/publications/i/item/9789289054553
  13. Liu T, Lee JKQ, Kanagawa HS, et al. Impacts of participatory arts-based interventions on well-being of older adults without dementia: an umbrella review and a conceptual artistic participation framework. The Gerontologist, 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12854778
  14. Liu W, Chen Q, Yang F, Zheng X. Comparative effects of different interventions on loneliness, social support, and depression in older adults: a network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Geriatric Nursing, 2026. europepmc.org/article/MED/42407321
  15. Wang Y, Xu Y, Gao L, Bai X. Impact of social prescribing on quality of life and loneliness in geriatric populations: a comprehensive meta-analysis of RCTs with implications for nursing practice. Geriatric Nursing, 2026. europepmc.org/article/MED/42167082
  16. Son D. Cultural prescribing: concepts, evidence, implementation, and the contribution of socially engaged art. Yonago Acta Medica, 2026. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC13503122
  17. Allison TA, Johnson JK, Stewart AL, et al. Facilitators and barriers to sustainment of a community choir program to promote health among diverse older adults: a multi-site study. International Journal of Community Music, 2025. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC12326659