Intergenerational Programmes and Loneliness: 14 Trials, No Clear Answer Yet
Published 2026-11-15
Bringing younger and older people together is one of the most popular ideas in work on later-life loneliness, but the hard evidence on loneliness itself is thin: a Campbell systematic review found 14 randomised trials of intergenerational programmes from six countries, all at high risk of bias, and could not say whether they change loneliness for older participants[1]. Studies more often report that the programmes change how the generations see each other; whether they leave older people less lonely has rarely been tested well.
The ideas are familiar to anyone who runs a community group: a nursery class that visits a care home every week, older volunteers reading in a primary school, a student who rents a spare room from an older householder, a day centre and a childcare centre that share a building and a garden. This study sets out what research worldwide measured, what the strongest studies found for older people, and where the gaps are. None of it shows that a programme will make any particular person less lonely.
Intergenerational programmes take many forms, and most of the research comes from the United States
An intergenerational programme here means one that brings together younger and older people who are not related. The Campbell Collaboration’s 2023 evidence and gap map, the most complete inventory we found, gathered 500 research articles of any design on such programmes, published over 46 years from 1975 to 2021 and conducted across 27 countries[2]. It found 26 systematic reviews and 236 quantitative comparative studies, of which only 38 were randomised controlled trials; the map’s authors did not appraise the quality of what they found[2].
The research is heavily American. By country of first author, 326 of the 500 studies came from the United States, against 33 from Canada, 29 from the United Kingdom, 27 from Australia and 15 from Japan[2]. Singapore had four studies and the Netherlands three[2], so the evaluation record is thin in some places where the idea has spread into housing and care policy, Singapore among them (see below). A finding from a US school cannot simply be carried over to a Japanese neighbourhood or a Dutch care home.
Most studies measured attitudes between the generations; few measured loneliness
In the Campbell map, attitudes towards the other generation were the most common outcome, reported in 283 studies, followed by mental wellbeing (224) and interactions between the generations (196)[2]. Loneliness and social isolation, counted together, were reported in 54[2]. Among its evidence gaps the map lists loneliness, social isolation and mental health outcomes for the children and young people taking part, and economic and adverse or unexpected outcomes[2].
On attitudes the picture is more encouraging. A 2026 scoping review of 69 studies of programmes designed to improve relationships between young and old found that reported outcomes “included more positive intergenerational attitudes and improved perceptions of relationship quality”, though fewer than half of the programmes set out the theory behind their design[3]. The World Health Organization’s 2023 guide for planning such programmes states that intergenerational contact “is one of three strategies that have been proven to work in addressing ageism”[4]. That matters in its own right: ageism shapes how older people are treated.
Yet older people themselves are often in the background of this research. A 2026 analysis of anti-ageism interventions found that outcomes “focus mainly on younger people and service providers, although older people are essential ingredients in the interventions”; in the few studies that assessed older participants the results were promising, but the authors found weaknesses in theory and methods throughout[5]. Most of this literature was not designed to ask whether older participants feel less lonely.
The strongest trials found no clear effect on older participants’ loneliness
The Campbell Collaboration’s 2023 systematic review searched the map, and ran its searches again in June 2023, for randomised trials reporting older people’s mental health or wellbeing. It found 14 trials from six countries: the United States, Japan, Italy, Spain, Australia and Canada[1]. Ten of the 14 were conducted in the United States[1]. They covered visiting programmes, school volunteering, music, reminiscence, language learning and shared projects, mostly delivered in person and often in groups[1].
The reviewers judged all 14 trials at high risk of bias: most scored well on only two or fewer of seven quality items, with particular concerns about blinding, allocation concealment and sample size[1]. Pooled results showed a small positive trend for self-esteem (effect size 0.33, 95% confidence interval −0.35 to 1.01, four studies, 254 older people, all using the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale) and for depression (effect size 0.19, −0.23 to 0.60); both intervals cross zero, and the authors wrote that “we cannot be confident about any effects”[1].
On loneliness the review’s plain-language summary concludes that “it is not clear if intergenerational interventions have any impact on quality of life, agitation, stress and loneliness in older people”, and that there is “no trial evidence” on social isolation for older people[1]. Only one of the 14 trials measured loneliness, a US foster grandparent programme in which older volunteers visited children in hospital: among 128 participants at one year, the effect size was 0.09 (95% confidence interval −0.4 to 0.58)[1], a result the reviewers grouped with others suggesting “no effect or even some small negative effects”[1]. The review found no long-term studies and no data on equity[1].
The largest trial found a positive result for a different outcome. In the US Experience Corps trial, older volunteers giving about 15 hours a week to elementary schools were compared with volunteers in roles with less contact with children (589 people in the analysis); after four months the Experience Corps group scored higher on generative achievement, a sense of contributing to younger generations (effect size 0.29, 95% confidence interval 0.13 to 0.45)[1]. In Japan, the REPRINTS programme trained older people to read picture books to children in schools, kindergartens and childcare centres; of 177 recruited, only 59 completed all assessments at six years, which shows how hard long follow-up is[1]. Purpose matters, but it is not loneliness. The wider evidence on older volunteers is covered in our study of volunteering in later life.
In care homes and shared sites, residents enjoyed the contact; loneliness was rarely measured
A 2022 meta-analysis of 13 studies (published 1993 to 2015) of intergenerational programmes for care-home residents living with dementia found that taking part “could improve the pleasure level and significantly reduce disengagement behaviours”, but brought “no apparent improvement in their quality of life, depression levels, and engagement levels”[6]. An earlier review of 27 sources on programmes linking older people with preschool and primary-age children described the effects on older participants as “variegated” across wellbeing, depression, self-reported health and self-esteem, while finding the programmes feasible even for people living with dementia[7].
In a small Australian pilot, nine residents of an aged care home with cognitive impairment and 13 children from an early learning centre on the same site met weekly for nine weeks in sessions designed by occupational therapists; residents valued the contact and family members and staff supported it, but “there did not appear to be any change in loneliness or neuropsychiatric symptoms”[8]. With nine older participants and no comparison group, a pilot like this cannot show an effect either way. Loneliness in care homes more broadly is covered in our study of loneliness in care homes.
Shared sites, where services for children and older people operate in one place, are the most ambitious form. A 2018 survey by Generations United and The Ohio State University set a baseline of 105 shared site programmes in the United States, from 193 responses[9]; one of the oldest, a residential community for older adults in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, opened with a childcare centre on its campus some 40 years before the report[9]. In Singapore, the Ministry of Health said in 2016 that it intended to co-locate eldercare and childcare facilities “in some 10 new public housing developments over the next 10 years”, starting with Kampung Admiralty, and that more than 70 schools had run its Inter-generational Learning Programme, involving more than 12,000 older people and students in total[10]. We found no published evaluation of loneliness outcomes for these Singapore sites. A Singapore feasibility trial of an intergenerational dance programme across six Active Ageing Centres, with 54 participants completing, measured quality of life, happiness and social support rather than loneliness, and found no significant differences between groups in its main analysis[11].
Homesharing and student phone calls: encouraging reports from weak designs
Homesharing matches an older householder who has a spare room with a younger person, usually a student, who pays reduced rent or none in return for company or help. A 2026 scoping review of homesharing between people aged 50 and over and university students found 63 eligible sources published between 1985 and 2024, from programmes in a range of countries[12]. Older participants were more often women, were described as experiencing social isolation, and were apprehensive about matching, student behaviour and money; participants “reported decreased loneliness and isolation, and having enjoyed the experience more than anticipated”, while some students found the support expected of them higher than they had thought[12]. A scoping review does not weigh study quality, so these are participants’ reports, not measured change against a comparison group.
In Ontario, Canada, the McMaster Phone-a-Friend programme matched older people at risk of social isolation with trained university student volunteers for weekly telephone calls during the COVID-19 pandemic. Of 220 active participants in August 2021, 60 who had completed at least four calls answered a feedback survey, and 58.3% of them agreed or strongly agreed that they felt less lonely after taking part[13]. That is a single question answered by just over a quarter of participants, with no comparison group, so it cannot show whether the calls reduced loneliness. Telephone and in-person befriending more generally is covered in our study of befriending.
Two cautions apply to most evaluations of this kind. People who sign up may differ from those who do not in health, confidence and social ties. And programmes that recruit people because they are lonely will tend to see scores fall on average even without any effect (regression to the mean), so an uncontrolled before-and-after improvement is not evidence that a programme worked.
What the evidence asks of us
None of this is a case against bringing generations together: participants value the contact, the evidence on attitudes and ageism is stronger, and the loneliness question is unanswered rather than answered no. The Campbell reviewers’ conclusions point to what would change that:
- Measure loneliness and isolation, for older participants as well as younger ones. The review calls for research to measure outcomes “for BOTH the older and younger population engaged in the intervention” and for more consistent, agreed outcome measures[1]. Evaluations claiming a loneliness benefit should name their scale and include a comparison group.
- Fund programmes for long enough to know. The review asks whether programmes last beyond initial research funding; its stakeholders said that programmes “initiated for research and then end (usually within a year) are not helpful”[1].
- Explain the logic and consider equity. Commissioners and developers should be clear why a programme is expected to work, and should consider who it reaches; the review found no data on equity[1].
- Plan contact carefully. WHO’s guide gives step-by-step planning advice for intergenerational contact[4], and the homesharing review recommends careful matching, clear written agreements and support throughout and at the end of each arrangement[12].
Public goodwill is not in doubt: in a 2018 online Harris Poll of 2,041 US adults commissioned for Generations United (not a probability sample), 92% said they believed intergenerational activities can help reduce loneliness across all ages[9]. That is a measure of belief, not of effect. The groups running these programmes deserve evaluation good enough to show whether the hopes are met. How intergenerational work compares with other approaches is set out in our study of what works for loneliness, and the full library is at Loneliness in Later Life.
Language: this piece says "older people" and treats loneliness as a common human experience that anyone can have, not a personal failing or an illness. It keeps apart three things that are often mixed up: loneliness (how people feel about their relationships), social isolation (how few social contacts they have) and living alone (a household arrangement). Where a study uses another term, such as "seniors" or "older adults", we keep it when quoting that study.
Why we're publishing this
Intergenerational work is close to the heart of many community groups, often run by older people themselves, who are asked by funders to show that it reduces loneliness. They are best served by an honest account of what the research does and does not show: better evidence that contact changes attitudes between the generations, warm accounts from participants, and very few rigorous tests of loneliness. Knowing the gaps helps groups make their case on the evidence that exists and press for better evaluation.
How to read this data
Most figures come from two Campbell publications: an evidence map, which counts studies without judging quality, and a review of randomised trials. Effect sizes are standardised differences between programme and comparison groups; a 95% confidence interval that crosses zero means the result is compatible with no effect. The map counts loneliness and social isolation together without recording scales, and the review’s table does not name the loneliness measure used in the one trial result reported here. Scoping reviews map what has been published without weighing quality, and the single-programme evaluations here lack comparison groups. Counts of shared sites are from a 2018 US survey and the Singapore figures from a 2016 government statement; both will have changed since.
Use this data
Free to cite with attribution to Understanding Aging. u3a groups, men's sheds, senior centres, lunch clubs, befriending services, charities, campaigners and journalists are welcome to reuse these figures and charts. For the underlying figures as a spreadsheet, get in touch.
Important: This article summarises published research and statistics for general information. It is not medical or care advice and cannot be used to diagnose, treat or predict anything about an individual. If loneliness, low mood or isolation is affecting your health or someone else’s, a doctor or another health professional can help, and local services for older people can often put you in touch with groups and support nearby.
Sources
- Whear R, Campbell F, Rogers M, et al. What is the effect of intergenerational activities on the wellbeing and mental health of older people?: A systematic review. Campbell Systematic Reviews, 2023. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC10546258
- Campbell F, Whear R, Rogers M, et al. Non-familial intergenerational interventions and their impact on social and mental wellbeing of both younger and older people: A mapping review and evidence and gap map. Campbell Systematic Reviews, 2023. europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC9934919
- Liu D, Woo BFY, Wu N, Wu VX, Ho CSH, Tam WWS. “Bridging generations”: A scoping review of non-familial intergenerational programs and their impact on relationships between old and young. International Psychogeriatrics, 2026. europepmc.org/article/MED/41539933
- World Health Organization. Connecting generations: planning and implementing interventions for intergenerational contact. WHO, 2023. who.int/publications/i/item/9789240070264
- Morrow-Howell N, Li S, Li A, Wininger C, Galucia N, Carpenter BD. There, but not there: older people in anti-ageism interventions. The Gerontologist, 2026. europepmc.org/article/MED/41693028
- Lu LC, Lan SH, Hsieh YP, Lan SJ. Effectiveness of intergenerational participation on residents with dementia: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Nursing Open, 2022. europepmc.org/article/MED/34021969
- Gualano MR, Voglino G, Bert F, Thomas R, Camussi E, Siliquini R. The impact of intergenerational programs on children and older adults: a review. International Psychogeriatrics, 2018. europepmc.org/article/MED/28988548
- D’Cunha NM, Holloway H, Cave B, et al. A pilot study of an intergenerational program for people in residential aged care with cognitive impairment and children from a co-located early learning centre during COVID-19. Dementia, 2024. europepmc.org/article/MED/38373711
- Generations United and The Eisner Foundation. All In Together: Creating Places Where Young and Old Thrive. Generations United, 2018. gu.org/app/uploads/2018/06/SignatureReport-Eisner-All-In-Together.pdf
- Ministry of Health, Singapore. Efforts to boost inter-generational harmony (reply to the Straits Times Forum, 22 October 2016). Ministry of Health, 2016. moh.gov.sg/newsroom/efforts-to-boost-inter-generational-harmony
- Wu XV, Tam WSW, Yap XY, et al. Intergenerational approach of community dance program for older adults in Singapore: a feasibility cluster-controlled trial. BMC Geriatrics, 2025. europepmc.org/article/MED/41327006
- Craswell A, Watson K, Sysak T, et al. Intergenerational homesharing between older adults and university students: a scoping review. The Gerontologist, 2026. europepmc.org/article/MED/42560862
- Ahuja M, Lewis K, Owais S, et al. Evaluation of a Student-Older Adult Telephone Befriending Program to Reduce Social Isolation During the COVID-19 Pandemic. Canadian Geriatrics Journal, 2026. europepmc.org/article/MED/41743972