The armed forces pension remedy (McCloud) lets eligible members choose between old-scheme and AFPS 15 benefits for service from 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2022.

If you were serving on or before 31 March 2012 and still serving after April 2015, the remedy may change what your forces pension is worth, and you will be asked to pick. Your service dates, your scheme and your discharge date all feed the remedy choice, so sending the form on this page earns a ring-back where the FCA-authorised adviser goes over them for nothing.

What is the armed forces pension remedy, and why does it exist?

The Ministry of Defence (MOD) calls it "the 2015 Pension Remedy, previously known as McCloud". When public service pensions were reformed in 2015, the MOD's booklet explains, members within ten years of normal retirement age were given transitional protection and stayed in their existing schemes, while other serving personnel moved into AFPS 15. Firefighters and judges challenged that in the courts, and in July 2019 the Government confirmed the discrimination applied across the public sector. A short MOD factsheet puts the finding plainly: "The courts found this difference in treatment amounted to unlawful age discrimination."

The fix came in two stages. The first, called the prospective remedy, closed the old schemes (AFPS 75, AFPS 05 and the related reserve and early departure schemes) to further pension building on 31 March 2022 and put every serving member into AFPS 15 from 1 April 2022. Pension already built in those schemes was kept. The second stage, the retrospective remedy, deals with the unequal treatment in between, and it took effect on 1 October 2023.

Which service was moved back into the legacy schemes?

The remedy period runs from 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2022. On 1 October 2023 the MOD "rolled back" eligible members, meaning it returned their service in that window to the legacy scheme they would have stayed in. This was a one-off re-attribution rather than a reopening: nobody builds new AFPS 75 or 05 pension for service after March 2022, and pension built before April 2015 or from April 2022 is untouched. Full-time reserve service in the window went back to RFPS 05.

Who counts as eligible is set by the Public Service Pensions and Judicial Offices Act 2022, section 1. In summary, you need to have been in qualifying service on 31 March 2012 or earlier, with no gap of more than five years before the service in question, and that service must fall in the remedy period. The MOD puts it more loosely, saying members need relevant service before 1 April 2012 and eligible service during the remedy period. Exact eligibility "depends on individual service history", so ask Defence Business Services (DBS) rather than assume you are in or out. Which armed forces pension scheme you are on sets out how the 1975, 2005 and 2015 schemes differ.

When do you have to choose between your old scheme and AFPS 15?

The choice is not made on 1 October 2023 or at any set date. The MOD says most people in service after that date "will not need to take any action until they are near their retirement date". When you choose depends on which group you fall in:

Your positionWhen the choice arrivesTime to reply
Serving, due an immediate pension or Early Departure Payment on leavingStatement sent on the Joint Personnel Administration system 9 months before you leave6 months, and the administrator needs your decision at least 3 months before payment
Left service, pension deferredMOD writes about 12 months before payment to confirm your address; statement follows 9 months before payment6 months from the date the statement is issued
Already receiving a pension or EDP before 1 October 2023Statement issued as soon as practicable12 months from the date of issue
Discharged at short notice or on medical groundsOn medical discharge the statement may not arrive until close to your final date; if you have not chosen by your last day, legacy benefits are paid until you choose or the election period ends, whichever is sooner6 months

Table source: MOD, Your 2015 Pension Remedy, Explained (V8, May 2026), chapter 2.

If you say nothing, the result is not neutral. "The default position where no choice is made, is to pay legacy scheme benefits for the remedy period". Members who have not yet been paid can change their election up to one month before the pension starts; anyone who is already receiving a pension is told that "Once you have made your election, this cannot be reversed." You make the choice on the claim form, Pension Form 1 for serving members or Form 8 for deferred ones, sent on paper to DBS. How this timing interacts with the age you can first claim is covered in armed forces pension age.

Choosing between two sets of benefits for the same years is exactly where a second pair of eyes helps. Comparing the statement's two columns with your civilian income is a job for a longer talk than a letter allows; this page's form requests one, and nobody charges you for the FCA-authorised adviser's time.

What if you have already left or retired?

Your pension keeps being paid while you wait. If your pension or Early Departure Payment was in payment before 1 October 2023 you are an immediate-choice member: you "will continue to receive your current benefits until you make your choice", and a change, if you pick the other scheme, is backdated to when your benefits became payable. If you make no choice within the 12 months, legacy benefits become the default.

Some situations need extra steps:

  • You opted out. The scheme administrator writes to let you apply to opt back in for the remedy period, which means proving you are eligible; you also receive a reinstatement statement.
  • You transferred out. A transfer made before 1 October 2023 is topped up to the higher of the two valuations; after that date, the higher value is the one sent. More in can I transfer my armed forces pension.
  • The member has died. An eligible decision maker makes the election for them. Dependants' pensions are in armed forces pension death benefits.
  • You left without a statement. Contact DBS on 0800 085 3600 (overseas 0044 141 224 3600) or write to JPAC, Mail Point 380, Kentigern House, 65 Brown Street, Glasgow G2 8EX.

What does a Remediable Service Statement tell you?

A Remediable Service Statement (RSS) is the document the choice hangs on. It is personal to you, and it compares what the legacy scheme and AFPS 15 would each pay for the remedy period, which the MOD says can include pension, lump sum and other benefit information. Two kinds exist. An annual RSS is for information only; active members receive one each year after the first, and a deferred member can request one free of charge. An election RSS is the one that asks you to act.

The MOD cautions against judging by size alone: "The 'highest pension' is not always the whole answer." Its factsheet adds: "Different options can affect annual pension, lump sums and survivor benefits." The statement is also the place to look if your pension is affected by divorce, by a transfer, by abatement after re-joining, or by medical discharge, since each can change the comparison. If anything on it looks wrong, contact DBS and quote the reference number printed on it.

Statements have been slow to arrive. The MOD's delivery update says that as of 17 August 2026 it had issued 99,077, with 11,770 Immediate Choice statements still to go and the next update due in December 2026. Statements are not sent to members whose address DBS cannot trace, so a deferred member who has moved should send DBS their current address. For a rough sense of what a forces pension pays at all, how much an army pension is explains the calculation; the MOD's own pension calculator is described as "for illustrative purposes only", and the remedy comparison itself sits in your RSS.

Contributions, interest, tax and compensation

  • Voluntary contributions. AFPS 15 Added Pension bought in the remedy period "is revoked and a compensation payment made", and the refund is net of the tax relief given. People rolled back to AFPS 75 or 05 can apply, subject to conditions and while still serving as a regular member, to buy retrospective extra service in those schemes; in AFPS 05 that means showing they would have bought it had they not been moved to AFPS 15.
  • Back-payments and interest. If your election means the pension should have been higher, the arrears are paid with interest. The MOD's May 2026 booklet says the judgement rate, "currently at 8%", is broadly the starting rate when money is owed to you. If it means you were overpaid, the amount is recovered with compound interest at the NS&I Direct Saver rate, which the booklet says will usually be lower than the rate used when the scheme owes you. Arrears owed each way are netted off where possible.
  • Tax. The MOD says "Most people’s tax position will be unaffected by a remedy election." If the move between schemes alters your pension growth for a past tax year, you will be sent an R-PSS, a pension savings statement adjusted for the remedy; see whether your armed forces pension is taxable for the everyday position.
  • Losses the remedy misses. You can claim compensation for direct financial loss, such as fees for financial advice taken when AFPS 15 came in, and make a contingent decision claim if a pension or career decision you made because of the 2015 changes is not dealt with. For a contingent decision claim the MOD "strongly" advises waiting for your first RSS. Non-financial loss is not compensated.

Loose ends on the forces remedy

Can I use a calculator to work out my remedy choice?

The figures you need come from your own statement, which is built on your service record. The Armed Forces Pension Calculator on GOV.UK is aimed at active regular and reserve personnel and gives only an illustration.

Where does the MOD send people who want help reading a statement?

To DBS first, for questions about your award and statement. Its statement FAQs also list MoneyHelper, Citizens Advice and the Services Insurance and Investment Advisory Panel, a group of advisers to the forces that the MOD recognises.

Does the remedy matter if I am divorced?

It can. A pension sharing order is one of the cases that can slow a statement down, and the debit is shown on it. See armed forces pension and divorce.

Do medical and dental officers choose differently?

They choose the same way, but a medical or dental officer who picks AFPS 15 style benefits must repay the part of their AFPS 05 bonus that relates to the remedy period, with interest.

Do other public sector pensions have the same remedy?

The same court ruling led to remedies elsewhere, each with its own rules and dates. Compare police, NHS, teachers and civil service versions.

To have a forces statement talked through on the phone, complete the form on this page; DBS, MoneyHelper and Citizens Advice are open to you first if you prefer.

Sources: MOD, Your 2015 Pension Remedy, Explained (V8, May 2026); MOD, Armed Forces Pension Remedy factsheet (Pension Awareness Week 2026); MOD, RSS Delivery Update (figures to August 2026); MOD, RSS FAQs for active and deferred members (May 2025); MOD, Armed Forces Pension Tax factsheet (2026); legislation.gov.uk, Public Service Pensions and Judicial Offices Act 2022, section 1. Read 3 and 4 November 2026 (tax factsheet 18 October 2026).