A wrong pension quote does not usually bind the scheme, but if you relied on it and lost out, you can query it and complain.
Can a pension quote be a promissory estoppel in the UK, so that a scheme must pay the figure it gave you? Not on its own, as a general rule. The Pensions Ombudsman says a scheme or employer that gives you incorrect information is “not automatically bound by it”, though you may have a complaint if you acted on the figure and lost money. Quoted one figure and told another? What the lower amount means for your retirement plans is something to discuss with an FCA-authorised adviser when you request a free call in this page’s short form.
Does a wrong pension quote bind the scheme?
Generally not. The Ombudsman’s guidance explains that your entitlement “is set out in the rules of your pension scheme” and that “An incorrect quote does not change your entitlement.” In most cases you are only entitled to the correct benefits under those rules, even if that amount is lower than what you were told.
The guidance treats incorrect information as anything you are told about your pension that is factually wrong. Its examples are:
- a benefit statement with wrong figures, either once or over several years
- a retirement quote given shortly before you retire that turns out to be wrong
- wrong information about joining, leaving, or becoming entitled to benefits
- a failure to give you information when a deadline or time-sensitive requirement applies
The State Pension is different: complaints about it go to DWP rather than the Ombudsman, as a question near the end of this page explains.
What should I do if I think a figure is wrong?
Query it with the scheme straight away. The guidance says that if a figure “seems high given your contributions or length of service”, you should not rely on it to make any financial decisions, and that once you know of a mistake you must take steps to limit any further financial loss. Our guide to reading a pension statement shows what the headline numbers on one usually mean, which helps you work out what to ask about.
Keep every document that carries the figure. If you do end up complaining to the Ombudsman, you will need copies of the papers that contain the incorrect information, along with your correspondence with the scheme.
When might a scheme have to put things right?
The Ombudsman looks at three questions: was the information you received incorrect, was it reasonable for you to rely on it, and did you suffer a financial loss as a result. If you could not reasonably have spotted the mistake yourself, and you made a decision based on it that caused you a financial loss, the scheme “may be required to put you back in the position you would have been in had the error not occurred”. That applies only where the wrong information directly led you to a decision you would not otherwise have made.
The remedy is not the same as the promised pension. According to the Ombudsman, what it can direct “is usually not the same as directing them to pay you the benefits set out in the incorrect information”, though in limited cases it can direct benefits different from those in the scheme rules. Money you can recover, for example by selling something you bought because of the figure, does not count as a loss.
Typical complaints include retiring early or cutting working hours on the strength of a wrong figure, or making a major purchase because of one. Your own papers decide whether any of this applies. Already stopped work or spent money because of the old figure? Rebuilding your retirement budget around the corrected pension is something an FCA-authorised adviser could map out with you, without charge; the form here is how that phone call gets booked.
The Ombudsman will not usually uphold a complaint where:
- you were told one level of benefit and later a different one, but suffered no financial loss
- your financial decisions would have been the same with correct information
- the information included wording that it was not final, though that may not apply if other things reasonably led you to treat it as final
- you should reasonably have spotted that it was wrong
Can a pension quote be a promissory estoppel in the UK?
Estoppel is a legal doctrine, and the Ombudsman’s guidance describes it in connection with overpayments, where a scheme tries to recover money already paid. In that setting it protects money already paid to you; for a wrong quote, the Ombudsman instead asks the three questions about incorrect information, reliance and loss set out above. In that guidance, it may apply if you can show, with evidence, that the scheme made you reasonably believe the amount was correct, you made irreversible financial decisions believing that, you would suffer if you had to repay, and it would be unfair to require repayment.
The same page adds a warning: “Pension estimates alone usually aren’t enough to qualify for this defence.” Information that said it was not final or binding makes it “unlikely that you can say you reasonably relied on it”. What this means for a particular case is for the scheme and, if necessary, the Ombudsman to weigh; our guide to pension overpayments covers the recovery side in full.
How do I complain about a wrong pension quote?
Start by raising it with the scheme, informally. If that does not settle it, put a formal complaint in writing to whoever you think is at fault: the employer, the trustees or the administrator. For a workplace scheme this normally means its Internal Dispute Resolution Procedure (IDRP), usually in two stages of up to four months each. A personal pension follows the provider’s own process, so ask for a written reply.
Once you hold a final response you are unhappy with, you may be able to take the matter to the Ombudsman. The usual limit is three years from the event or from when you became aware, or reasonably should have become aware, of the problem, if that is later. How the Pensions Ombudsman works explains who can complain and what follows an application.
The Ombudsman can also look at distress and inconvenience. It says it will consider whether you were affected in ways that are not financial and that, if the impact is “significant” or above under its guidance, it can direct the organisation at fault to compensate you; if not, an award is unlikely. Its factsheet, updated September 2018 and now headed “Currently under review - March 2026”, gives a usual starting point of £500 for significant injustice, so check the current version before relying on that amount. Free help with the paperwork is listed in where to get free pension help.
Estimates, State Pension forecasts and bad advice
Is a pension estimate the same as a quote?
Both can count. The Ombudsman’s examples of incorrect information include a benefit statement with wrong figures and a retirement quote given shortly before you retire. Either way, wording that the figure was not final usually counts against a complaint, so read the small print on whatever you were sent.
What if the wrong figure was a State Pension forecast?
That is for DWP, not the Pensions Ombudsman. State Pension back payments covers asking for a decision to be looked at again, and the State Pension guide covers the basics.
Does the Ombudsman cover bad pension advice?
That is a different route. The Ombudsman says complaints about how a pension was sold or marketed, or about a financial adviser, belong with the Financial Ombudsman Service. An error by the scheme itself is its own territory.
After the scheme confirms the right figure
A corrected figure can alter more than one decision: when to stop work, what to do with other savings, whether a transfer or lump sum still makes sense. Pension Wise gives free guidance on defined contribution pensions. Once the scheme confirms the real figure, you can test your retirement date, lump sum or planned purchases against it with an FCA-authorised adviser, free; the form on this page gets the conversation started.