AVC pension vs SIPP compares two kinds of product, not two firms: an AVC is paid through a scheme you already belong to, a SIPP is a pension you open yourself.

AVC pension vs SIPP: what each one is

MoneyHelper describes voluntary contributions as the case where "you pay in more than the minimum required by your scheme." That is the AVC. A self-invested personal pension (SIPP), in MoneyHelper's words, "lets you decide how your pension money is invested – usually offering a wider selection than other pension types." Neither is ranked above the other here, because which one is open to you depends on your scheme. Anyone weighing a scheme AVC against a SIPP of their own can request a call-back here from an FCA-authorised adviser, whose time on the call is free.

The two meet where a scheme has no AVC, or you would like a different provider. MoneyHelper says you can then start a new pension, and that all pensions you can set up yourself are defined contribution, so what they pay "largely depends on how much is paid in and how well the investments perform – there are no guarantees." An older pension of that kind, set up beside a workplace scheme, may be called a free-standing AVC (FSAVC). For the AVC basics see what an AVC pension is; for the SIPP basics, what a SIPP is.

AVC and SIPP side by side

Each column gives that product's own rules. An AVC varies by scheme, so the AVC examples come from the LGPS (the local government scheme) and the NHS scheme; yours may differ.

PointAVCSIPPSource
What it isIn a defined benefit scheme, either extra guaranteed benefit in the existing pension or a separate invested potA defined contribution pension you set up yourselfMoneyHelper (AVC page; SIPP page), read 27 Oct and 1 Nov 2026
Who chooses the providerThe scheme arranges it: each LGPS fund has an in-house AVC provider, and the NHS scheme managers select the MPAVC providers. A free-standing AVC lets you chooseYou choose the providerLGPS, read 30 Oct 2026; NHSBSA members guide (V13); MoneyHelper
How you pay inLGPS: taken directly from your payYou arrange payment with the provider; it is not taken from wagesLGPS; MoneyHelper AVC page (on a pension you set up yourself)
Investment choiceLGPS: you decide how your pot is invested. NHS: invested in line with your wishesYou can often decide, with a wider range than other pension types; the range depends on the providerLGPS; NHSBSA; MoneyHelper
Limit on paying inLGPS in-house AVC: up to 100% of pensionable payNormally cannot start or pay in after age 75, unless transferring an existing pensionLGPS; MoneyHelper
Earliest accessUsually 55 (57 from April 2028); defined benefit AVCs often do not pay out until the scheme's normal retirement ageUsually 55 (57 from April 2028), unless you must retire early because of poor healthMoneyHelper
Tax-free cashUsually up to 25% of any pension (the same as a SIPP); a defined benefit AVC might let you take a lump sum without reducing your regular incomeUp to 25% as tax-free cashGOV.UK lump sum allowance; MoneyHelper (AVC page; SIPP page)

Does tax relief work the same way on an AVC and a SIPP?

Not by default. HMRC's rules cap relief at "up to 100% of your annual earnings", but it can arrive by two automatic routes. Under one, "your employer takes workplace pension contributions out of your pay before deducting Income Tax"; the LGPS takes its AVCs this way, so relief comes without any claim. Under the other, "your pension provider claims tax relief from the government at the basic 20% rate and adds it to your pension pot", which MoneyHelper says most personal pension providers do for a SIPP.

Pay Income Tax above 20% and the SIPP route leaves extra relief to claim through Self Assessment. A free-standing AVC is arranged with a provider of your choice, so ask that provider which route it uses. Net pay and relief at source compares the routes, and pension tax relief has the general rules.

Allowances that count both together

Here the two are treated alike. The annual allowance covers all your private pensions together, so AVC and SIPP payments add up with everything else you save. For 2026/27 the figure on GOV.UK is £60,000, which it says can be lower, for example after flexibly accessing a pension. The annual allowance page explains, and the lower allowance after flexible access has that case.

The lump sum allowance is shared too. GOV.UK says the usual tax-free lump sum is a quarter of the pot, capped at £268,275, and what you have already taken counts across every scheme you are in. Any invested pot, in either product, can go down in value as well as up. How the pot is later turned into income is covered in AVC retirement options and pension drawdown.

Can an AVC be moved into a SIPP?

Sometimes, and each scheme sets its own terms. The LGPS gives members a right to transfer an AVC, with conditions that include these: payments into every LGPS AVC must have stopped, every LGPS AVC plan moves together, and for current members the move must come before the LGPS benefits are paid. It adds that a transferred AVC may be usable in ways the LGPS does not offer. That is the LGPS rule; the NHS scheme, the Teachers' Pension Scheme and others set their own terms, so check with your scheme or its AVC provider.

MoneyHelper's advice before any pension transfer is to "check if your existing pension schemes have any special features or guarantees – and if there are exit fees or other penalties for leaving". The LGPS also warns that scammers operate in AVC transfers; see pension scams and how to transfer a pension. For opening one, how to open a SIPP goes through the steps.

What to find out before you pay in extra

Because neither product is better in every case, the useful questions are about your own situation:

  • Does your scheme offer an AVC, and does it add to your scheme pension or build a separate pot?
  • If you are weighing a SIPP, which provider charges what for the investments you would want, and can you pay in the way you need?
  • When might you need the money, given the earliest-access rules above?
  • Does your employer help with either route? Employer payments into a personal pension or SIPP and salary sacrifice versus AVCs cover that.

Your scheme's AVC terms, the SIPP charges you would face and your tax position all meet on one call, which this page's form arranges for free. Pension Wise (what Pension Wise is) separately offers free guidance on taking money from a defined contribution pot.

AVC or SIPP: your questions

SIPP vs AVC: which should I choose?

Neither is better for everyone. It depends on whether your scheme offers an AVC, what it buys, the charges on each, how much investment choice you want and when you need access. Are AVC pensions worth it and personal pension vs SIPP cover each side.

Is it possible to have an AVC and a SIPP together?

Yes. MoneyHelper's SIPP guide says you can hold a SIPP beside a workplace pension, or any number of pension types, though each provider will typically charge you; the annual allowance counts all your private pensions together.

Do an AVC and a SIPP have charges?

MoneyHelper says a SIPP provider "will likely take charges from your pension pot to cover the cost of investing". AVC charges depend on the provider your scheme uses, so ask your pension fund or that AVC provider for the charges on the funds you would pick.

How is a Teachers' Pensions AVC different?

Teachers' Pensions says AVC contributions "build up an additional pension that is separate to your teacher's pension", with a provider the Department for Education has arrangements with, though you can use others. See Teachers' Pension AVCs.

Where does salary sacrifice come in?

That is a way of paying, not a third product. Pension salary sacrifice vs AVC sets it out, and final salary pension AVCs covers defined benefit schemes.

Sources