Aviva pension vs Scottish Widows: Aviva's SIPP charges 0.35% a year on the first £500,000, the Scottish Widows SIPP 0.25% capped at £16.50 a month, and its Ready-Made Pension 0.3% with a £5 monthly minimum.

There is no overall winner here, because the two firms sell different things to different savers. Would an FCA-authorised adviser set these terms against your own pensions? Submit this page's short form and one phones you back, free of charge. Values can fall as well as rise, so you may get back less than you paid in.

Aviva pension vs Scottish Widows: which products are being compared?

Aviva's online personal pension is a self-invested personal pension (SIPP), which Aviva describes as "a type of personal pension which usually offers you a much wider choice of investments". Scottish Widows has two: a Ready-Made Pension, where the firm chooses the investments, and a SIPP where you do. Both Scottish Widows products are provided by Embark Investment Services Limited, with the Ready-Made Pension investing in assets managed by Scottish Widows Unit Trust Managers Limited.

So the fair pairing is Aviva's SIPP against each Scottish Widows product in turn. Each firm has its own page, Aviva pension plan and is Scottish Widows pension good.

Aviva vs Scottish Widows pension charges and fees

Aviva Pension (SIPP)Scottish Widows Ready-Made PensionScottish Widows SIPP
Account chargeThe Aviva Charge: 0.35% a year on the first £500,000 of your investments with Aviva, nothing above that; no charge on cash0.3% a year, taken monthly, minimum £5 a month0.25% a year of your SIPP investments' value, uninvested cash excluded, capped at £16.50 a month (£198 a year)
Buying and sellingFunds: free. UK shares, ETFs and investment trusts: £4.99 a trade–Online UK shares: £5 a trade, discounts could apply. International shares and funds: nil, though a 1.5% exchange rate applies
Fund charges on topEach fund or ETF has its own charge, taken from that investment's value rather than by AvivaFund managers take 0.1% ongoing, transaction costs up to 0.19%Typically 0.25% to 1.5% ongoing, transaction costs around 0.5%, depending on the fund
Transferring in or outNo charge for transfers, though other providers mayNo charge for transfersNo charge to transfer in or away
Taking benefitsNo separate charge currentlyNo charge to accessNo additional charge in flexi-access drawdown

The cells draw on Aviva's SIPP page, charges page and key features (print reference RD01002_0726), and on Scottish Widows' compare page, Ready-Made Pension page and SIPP key features (print reference WOMSIPP KFD 0007 (0726 IH)), all read between 26 October and 2 November 2026. Scottish Widows says its charges are "reviewed regularly and could change in the future".

Aviva's own example puts the Aviva Charge at £350 a year on £100,000 invested; Scottish Widows prints its SIPP cap as £198 a year. Funds, trades and cash interest add to either. Aviva says it retains some of the interest earned on money in your cash account; the Scottish Widows SIPP key features say Embark keeps all interest earned while money sits briefly in its central transaction account. Each firm's own sums are in Aviva pension charges and Scottish Widows pension fees, with the wider picture in pension charges explained.

Funds, minimums and who can open one

Aviva offers its own managed funds and an expert shortlist alongside "more than 5,000 self-select funds", plus UK shares, ETFs and investment trusts, and says you can start from £25 a month. Scottish Widows' Ready-Made Pension needs at least £120 a month, a £4,000 single payment or £10,000 of transfers, and places you in a retirement portfolio chosen by the year you plan to start taking money. Its SIPP starts from £1 and has a managed "Start-Up" fund for people who want a packaged option; its key features list direct property and gold bullion among the things it does not offer. More is in Aviva pension funds and Scottish Widows pension funds.

On eligibility, Aviva says its pension might suit someone aged 18 or over, and that it is "unable to accept new payments from age 75 although transfers may still be accepted". Scottish Widows takes applications for either pension from people aged 18 to under 75 who are UK resident for tax purposes. Aviva's page notes that higher and additional-rate relief can reach 48% in Scotland, against 45% elsewhere.

Taking your money: drawdown, lump sums and annuities

Both start from the same minimum pension age: Aviva says you normally need to be 55, "rising to 57 from 6 April 2028", and Scottish Widows' key features give the same ages. Aviva says drawdown payments can be taken "as and when you need them and/or on a regular basis", but "you can't set up regular lump sum payments", and the money has to be in your cash account or payment may take longer. Scottish Widows' SIPP asks for enough uninvested cash to cover any one-off or regular income, and says it reserves an additional 1% of a withdrawal for pending transactions and investment movement.

Annuities differ. Aviva says you can buy one from Aviva but not through its online investment service. Scottish Widows says its Ready-Made Pension and SIPP do not offer an annuity option, though it can help you find a provider that does. Aviva says taking taxable drawdown money, and Scottish Widows says starting an income, triggers a limit on later contributions; the Money Purchase Annual Allowance is £10,000 for 2026/2027, Aviva says. Step-by-step routes are in pension drawdown explained, Aviva pension withdrawal and how to access a Scottish Widows pension. Whether drawdown or an annuity fits your own pots and health is a question an adviser can talk through free once you complete the form here.

If your pension comes through an employer

Here the choice usually is not yours. Aviva says "Your employer will usually set up your workplace pension for you without you having to ask", and in one Aviva company scheme guide the annual fund charge is one your employer announces: "Your employer will tell you how much this charge is." In the Scottish Widows Master Trust, the trustees report charges for each default and alternative fund option, and employers "may select a different default investment option for their section". A figure from the personal pension table above may therefore not be what your scheme charges; your statement or scheme documents show it. The People's Pension comparison looks at workplace schemes more widely.

Aviva or Scottish Widows pension: pros, cons and the savers they may fit

  • The Aviva Pension (SIPP) may suit someone comfortable choosing their own funds or shares, who likes one percentage account charge, free fund trades and a £25 monthly start. It may not suit someone who wants an annuity bought inside the online service or regular lump sums set up.
  • The Scottish Widows Ready-Made Pension may suit someone who wants the firm to pick and gradually adjust the investments. Scottish Widows itself says it might not be right for someone who wants choice or control over how the pension is invested.
  • The Scottish Widows SIPP may suit someone who will make their own investment decisions and values a cap on the account charge. It may not suit someone who wants property held directly.

Old pensions with guarantees can be a snag at either: Aviva will not accept a pension with guaranteed annuity rates or other safeguarded benefits, and the Scottish Widows SIPP lists the same kinds among the transfers it cannot take. Moving one is covered in Scottish Widows pension transfer. Neither column can weigh your pots, tax and health together; an FCA-authorised adviser can, and the ring-back is free when you submit the enquiry form here.

Performance, reviews and pot size: your questions

How does Aviva pension performance compare with Scottish Widows?

Scottish Widows says the value of its SIPP "depends on the level of risk and potential performance of the investments you choose", and adds: "Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results." A fair figure therefore depends on the funds held, not just the firm.

Where do I find reviews of Aviva and Scottish Widows pensions?

A star score cannot show your own charges, funds or access rules, which are the parts you can check in the table above. For anything personal, read the key features and your latest statement.

Does pot size change which costs less?

It can, as each charge is built differently: Aviva's applies only to the first £500,000, the Ready-Made fee has a £5 monthly minimum and the SIPP charge is capped. Scottish Widows warns that when a SIPP is small and you deal regularly in smaller amounts, "dealing costs could be disproportionately high".

Is switching between Aviva and Scottish Widows free?

Both say they do not charge for transfers, though your existing provider may. Pensions already in drawdown cannot be moved into either, according to Aviva's transfer page and the Scottish Widows compare page.