Aviva vs Legal & General pension compared: Aviva's SIPP costs 0.35% annually for the first £500,000 held, L&G's Personal Pension a 0.25% service charge plus fund costs.
Searching for an Aviva vs Legal & General pension comparison turns up two pairings: the plans you open yourself, and the plans an employer picks. Each firm is described here through its own key features and web pages, with no overall winner declared. Which of these fits depends on the rest of your savings. Weighing Aviva against L&G for yourself? Via the form on this page, request a no-fee phone talk; an FCA-authorised adviser takes both firms' plans in turn.
Aviva's SIPP and L&G's Personal Pension: two different kinds of plan
Without an employer, you can open the Aviva Pension, called a self-invested personal pension in Aviva's key features (print reference RD01002_0726), or the L&G Personal Pension (key features Q0059826, April 2026). The workplace versions are separate products: Aviva's company pension schemes, and L&G's WorkSave and Group Stakeholder plans. Each firm's range is walked through in the Aviva pension plan and whether an L&G pension is good.
Aviva vs Legal & General pension costs, minimums and transfer rules in one table
Each cell is that firm's own statement, dated as the source dates it; where a document prints no date, the date is when it was read.
| Aviva Pension (SIPP) | L&G Personal Pension | |
|---|---|---|
| Main charge | "The Aviva Charge is 0.35% each year on the first £500,000 of your investments with us. There’s no charge on any investments above £500,000." (SIPP page, read 26 October 2026) | "The service charge is 0.25% of the value of your Pension per annum, calculated daily and deducted monthly." (key features, April 2026) |
| Fund charges | May apply on top, as fund management fees or an ongoing charges figure, depending on what you pick (SIPP page, read 26 October 2026) | The fund management charge differs from fund to fund (key features, April 2026); L&G's product page (read 2 November 2026) quotes a 0.31% fund charge but does not say which fund it applies to |
| Starting | From £25 a month (read 26 October 2026) | £100 one-off, then £1; transfers from £1 (April 2026) |
| Investment choice | More than 5,000 self-select funds and ready-made funds, plus UK shares, ETFs and investment trusts at £4.99 per trade (read 26 October 2026) | A default investment option, or five diversified funds chosen by risk appetite (read 2 November 2026) |
| Paying in | No new payments from age 75, though transfers may still be accepted (print reference RD01002_0726) | Payments until 75 (product page, read 2 November 2026); the key features (April 2026) call it suitable for customers aged between 18 and 74 |
| Cannot be moved in | Any defined benefit pension, and any DC pension carrying a guaranteed annuity rate or other safeguarded benefit (print reference RD01002_0726) | Pensions L&G says it can't consolidate include final salary, With Profits and guaranteed-rate plans (read 2 November 2026) |
| Drawdown entry | No minimum amount to move into drawdown (print reference RD01002_0726) | Full transfers into drawdown only, and no more contributions afterwards (April 2026) |
| Cost of taking money | No separate charge for taking retirement benefits at present (print reference RD01002_0726) | No charge for withdrawing money (April 2026) |
Fuller charge breakdowns are on Aviva pension charges and Legal & General pension fees. Aviva's charge covers administering your investments, while L&G splits its costs into a service charge and a fund charge, so the two headline numbers do not measure the same slice of cost.
L&G's one-time tax-free cash, Aviva's lump sum option and the MPAA
The money purchase annual allowance (MPAA) lowers the tax-relieved amount you can pay into money purchase pensions after you first access one flexibly. Each firm words its trigger its own way.
Aviva's key features put the MPAA under the plan's lump sum option, where one payment carries both the taxable part and the tax-free part: "Taking a lump sum will trigger the Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA)." On drawdown they say "Taking income drawdown payments may trigger the MPAA". L&G's say "If you haven’t flexibly accessed any of your existing pension benefits your first income payment from this plan will trigger the MPAA", and that you can take "your tax-free cash payment, and/or purchase a guaranteed income (annuity) for life without triggering the Money Purchase Annual Allowance". Under its Drawdown heading, L&G adds: "If you don’t take the full 25% when you set up your plan, our product doesn’t currently allow you to take the tax-free allowance later." For the practical steps, see L&G pension withdrawal, Aviva pension withdrawal and pension drawdown.
Online accounts, risk warnings and pension age: the common ground
Both are run online, and each warns that you can get back less than you paid in. Both tie access to the normal minimum pension age: Aviva's key features give it as 55, rising to 57 from 6 April 2028 except for anyone with a protected pension age, and L&G's give the same ages, with earlier access possible for a Protected Pension Age or ill-health retirement.
For workplace plans, both leave the main rate to the employer. Aviva's guide for company scheme members (print reference SP03303_0826) says "Your employer will tell you the annual fund charge percentage", while the June 2026 Group Stakeholder key features from L&G say its main charge, the BAMC, was agreed between L&G and your employer. Which scheme you are in therefore matters more than the brand.
Employer schemes: Aviva's value verdict and L&G's upgraded default rating
Workplace providers have independent governance committees (IGCs) that report on value for money. These verdicts cover the default strategies in employer schemes, not the Aviva SIPP or the L&G Personal Pension.
Aviva's 2026 report, for the year to 31 December 2025, concludes that "Aviva continues to provide good value for money for members of its workplace pension schemes". Its chart for policyholders in a default strategy shows 65% paying no more than 0.5% a year, and it describes the My Future Focus default as showing "middle-of-the-pack performance against its competitors".
L&G's committee, looking at the year to 31 December 2025, raised its rating for default funds and their performance to "Good", from "Acceptable, with areas for improvement" the year before, and says: "We think the new default funds have the potential to produce better growth for your pension pot over the long term and represent good value for money." The committees use different formats, so read both reports rather than lining them up word for word. Past performance is no guide to the future. How an employer's own plan compares is for that employer or the provider to show you.
Share-picker, short-menu saver or mid-transfer: matching the plan
The Aviva Pension may suit someone who wants shares, ETFs and investment trusts alongside funds and is content to pay the Aviva Charge on top of fund costs. Aviva's key features expect enough cash in the plan to cover charges. It may not suit someone holding a guaranteed annuity rate or a defined benefit pension they want to bring in.
The L&G Personal Pension may suit someone who wants a short menu of a default option or five funds. It may not suit someone who wants to move only part of a pot into drawdown or keep paying in once income starts, because its key features rule both out. Unsure whether the plan on your Aviva or L&G statement is a SIPP, personal pension or workplace plan? Whichever it turns out to be, the adviser phoning after your form lands will identify it free.
Other head-to-heads are Aviva against Scottish Widows and Aviva against Royal London; the wider Aviva picture is in Aviva pension reviews.
Aviva and L&G pensions: four quick checks
Does the lower headline percentage mean the cheaper plan?
The published figures measure different things, as the table shows. Pot size and fund choice decide the real cost, and pension charges explains each type.
Can I move an L&G pot to Aviva, or the reverse?
Each lists pensions it will not take in, shown in the table. Aviva's key features say it makes no charge for transfers, though other providers may. Costs on leaving a plan are in pension transfer fees.
Are workplace plans from either firm the same as the table?
No. They have separate documents and a charge agreed with the employer, so check your member paperwork and workplace pension charges.
Where do L&G's funds sit against Aviva's?
The firms describe their ranges differently. L&G's are in which Legal & General pension fund and Aviva's in Aviva pension funds.
With a pot at each firm, an FCA-authorised adviser could cover both in one free call; the quick form here is how to ask.