You can usually take up to 25% of an executive pension plan as tax-free cash, and a plan with protected tax-free cash from before April 2006 may allow more.

Can you take tax-free cash from an executive pension plan?

Yes, within the same limits as other pensions. GOV.UK says: "You can usually take up to 25% of the amount built up in any pension as a tax-free lump sum. The most you can take is £268,275." That ceiling is the lump sum allowance, and it adds up every pension you hold, not just one plan. Anything above your allowances is taxed as income. This page deals only with what is particular to an old executive plan; the plan itself is explained in what an executive pension plan is, and the general rules in the tax-free lump sum guide.

Before deciding anything, Pension Wise offers free, impartial, government-backed guidance from MoneyHelper. Hard-to-follow 2006 papers can be talked through by phone, free of cost, with an FCA-authorised adviser. Arranging that call uses the form on this page and little time.

The unusual part is that some executive plans date from when the old rules let a bigger share be paid as cash. That is where protected tax-free cash comes in.

What is protected tax-free cash in an executive pension plan?

It is a right, from before 6 April 2006, to a tax-free lump sum bigger than a quarter of the plan. HMRC's Pensions Tax Manual explains that "before 6 April 2006 some individuals had the right to be paid a tax-free lump sum of more than 25% of their total under a pension scheme", and calls the protection of that right scheme-specific lump sum protection. It attaches to one particular scheme, and it applies automatically: "there is no need for an individual or pension scheme administrator to claim this protection from HMRC".

Three eligibility conditions must all be met:

  • on 5 April 2006 you were a member of the scheme, or held the deferred annuity contract;
  • on that date your uncrystallised lump sum rights in that scheme were worth more than 25% of your total uncrystallised rights in it; and
  • you did not rely on enhanced or primary protection, or, if you did, your total lump sum rights were not more than £375,000.

People who held enhanced or primary protection have their own routes, set out in enhanced protection and primary protection. Having scheme-specific protection does not oblige the plan to pay the largest amount, because "this doesn't mean that a pension scheme has to pay the maximum allowable lump sum". Whether your plan's own rules allow it is a question for the trustees or the provider.

How much protected tax-free cash can the plan pay?

It is the cash you were entitled to on 5 April 2006, plus growth since. In HMRC's words, "the maximum permitted pension commencement lump sum will be the value of the individual's uncrystallised lump sum rights under the scheme on 5 April 2006, plus an additional amount which reflects any increase in the value of the individual's rights to benefits that has occurred since 6 April 2006".

The starting figure is not simply what the plan documents promised. Only lump sums that could have been paid under the tax regime in force before 5 April 2006 can be protected, so a promise above the old HMRC limits is cut back. Protected rights, and additional voluntary contributions started after 7 April 1987, could not be turned into cash under the old rules and are left out of the starting figure. Where the fund on that date was too small to provide the full old-limit cash, the lower amount counts.

A figure for your plan therefore needs the 2006 paperwork and a calculation by the scheme administrator. Once the call-back form reaches an adviser, they can walk you through those 2006 papers and the administrator's figure at no charge.

What conditions apply when protected cash is paid?

The lump sum still has to come with a pension. HMRC says the cash "must be paid in connection with becoming entitled to a relevant pension", and "because of this requirement, it is not possible to pay a 100% pension commencement lump sum". Three further conditions matter in practice:

  • Which scheme pays. The cash must come from the scheme that held the rights on 5 April 2006, or from another registered scheme that received them in a block transfer, or a series of block transfers, from that original scheme.
  • Same date. You must become entitled to all of your pension rights under the scheme on the same date, ignoring any pension already in payment on 5 April 2006. If you take more than one type of pension from the scheme, HMRC allows six months for all of them to start.
  • Minimum age. Most people cannot start before 55 (57 from 6 April 2028) unless an earlier protected pension age applies; see protected pension age.

A separate route exists for some plans. If on 5 April 2006 you could have taken the whole of your benefits as tax-free cash, HMRC says you may still be able to, as a stand-alone lump sum, provided several conditions are met. They include an age condition, taking all the scheme's untouched rights at once, and no relevant benefit accrual for you since that date. A trivial commutation payment can sit alongside protected cash only in very limited circumstances; trivial commutation explains the idea, and HMRC says the payment is taxable at your marginal rate.

How does protected cash fit with the lump sum allowance?

The allowances still count what you take. GOV.UK lists a pension commencement lump sum and a stand-alone lump sum among the payments that count towards the lump sum allowance, and gives £1,073,100 as the most that may be taken under the wider lump sum and death benefit allowance in certain circumstances. The old lifetime allowance was abolished in April 2024 (the lifetime allowance guide), and the lump sum and death benefit allowance page sets out the current limits.

Protected cash can go beyond the usual ceiling, but not tax-free without limit. HMRC's manual says a protected lump sum may be paid in full up to whatever lump sum and death benefit allowance you have left, rather than the £268,275 lump sum allowance, and that "the excess is taxed at the individual's marginal rate". Ask your provider how much of each allowance is already spent.

If you hold more than one pension, the amounts add together; taking a lump sum from two pensions covers that.

Can you lose protected tax-free cash by transferring?

Yes. HMRC states: "When benefits are transferred from one scheme to another, scheme-specific lump sum protection is lost unless the transfer is a block transfer." In HMRC's description, a block transfer is one transaction covering all the accrued rights of you and at least one other member of the scheme. That is the difficulty for executive plans with one member: HMRC says an occupational scheme "that only has one member, for example, an individual arrangement, cannot normally make a block transfer". The conditions are in block transfers, and the age equivalent in protected pension age on transfer.

HMRC adds that the receiving scheme can only qualify if you had been a member of it for no more than 12 months before the transfer date. And a partial transfer cannot be a block transfer: the part moved loses its protection, while the rights left behind keep it, though the protected lump sum is reduced by a formula that, among other things, deducts a quarter of the transfer value.

Check cash entitlements before asking for a transfer value. A transfer of promised benefits may also need advice first; the transfer advice rules and how to transfer a pension cover those steps. Winding up is the exception for a one-member plan: if the scheme winds up and all your rights move into one deferred annuity policy (a section 32 policy, for example) bought or assigned for you, HMRC treats that as a block transfer, subject to the payment conditions. Other winding-up transfers that are not block transfers lose the protection.

More about executive plan tax-free cash

Do I have to claim protected tax-free cash from HMRC?

No. HMRC's manual says the legislation applies scheme-specific protection automatically. What you need is evidence from the plan that the entitlement existed on 5 April 2006.

Is the tax-free cash from an executive plan always 25%?

No. It is usually up to 25%, but a protected plan may allow a larger share, subject to the conditions above and tax on any excess over your allowance.

Can I take every penny of an executive plan as cash?

Not as a pension commencement lump sum, because that must be linked to a pension. Only a stand-alone lump sum, with its own conditions, can pay everything tax-free; a small remainder may sometimes go as a taxable trivial commutation payment.

Who can tell me whether my plan is protected?

The trustees or provider keep the 2006 records. To have the cash question talked through, ask for the call-back the form here offers; it costs nothing.