Interactive Investor vs Vanguard SIPP: ii charges a flat monthly fee by plan; Vanguard charges £4 a month while your Vanguard investments total under £32,000, then 0.15% a year, capped at £375.

Both are self-invested personal pensions, but they are built differently: one is an open shelf of shares, funds and trusts, the other holds Vanguard's own funds only. Neither is ranked above the other; which fits turns on pot size, what you want to hold and how you plan to take money out. To see how ii, Vanguard or a mix would suit your other pensions, book a conversation (it is free) with an FCA-authorised adviser: just use this page's form.

Interactive Investor vs Vanguard SIPP at a glance

Interactive Investor (ii)Vanguard Personal Pension
Platform chargeFlat monthly fee by plan: Core £5.99 (portfolios up to £100,000, fee paid by Direct Debit, communications by email), Plus £14.99, Premium £39.99 (ii rates and charges, last updated 1 October 2026)Self-managed: £4 a month when your invested balance across all Vanguard accounts is below £32,000; 0.15% a year at £32,000 and above, maximum £375 a year (Vanguard self-managed costs and charges, dated 20 August 2026)
DealingPer trade; funds £3.99 on Core, £1.49 on Plus, free on Premium (same ii document)ETFs bought through Quote and Deal carry a fixed £7.50 charge, waived if you use ETF batch dealing, which groups trades twice a day (same Vanguard document)
What you can holdUK and international shares, funds, bonds, trusts and more, including over 1,000 ETFs (ii SIPP page, read 29 October 2026)"direct shares or any investment other than Vanguard Funds" are not presently permitted (key features, print date November 2025)
Taking income"There are no charges for taking an income from your pension" (ii drawdown page, read 26 October 2026)"we do not charge a fee when you want to start using your pension savings" (Vanguard transfer page, read 3 November 2026)
AnnuityListed as an alternative to drawdown, bought with another provider (ii drawdown page, read 26 October 2026)Not offered by Vanguard, which says it will transfer you to a new provider if you want one (Vanguard flexible income page, read 26 October 2026)
Transfer in"It’s always free to transfer with ii from our side" (ii transfer page, read 29 October 2026)No fee for transfers from Vanguard's side; your existing provider might charge (Vanguard transfer page, read 3 November 2026)

What you invest can lose value as well as grow, and returns are never guaranteed. Past performance is no guide, which is why none is quoted here.

Is the charge a flat fee or a percentage?

ii sets a fixed amount a month by plan. It says it will "never take a percentage of your wealth", and that your monthly fee "only covers your access to the ii investment platform and services", not "other costs like trading fees and foreign exchange". Part of the fee covers pension administration: £2.50 including VAT on Core, £6 including VAT on Plus and Premium. New accounts join Core, and ii moves you to Plus if your portfolio value exceeds £100,000.

Vanguard's self-managed account fee has two bands, set by the invested balance across all the accounts you hold with Vanguard, not counting cash. Below £32,000 it is £4 a month, which Vanguard puts at £48 a year. From £32,000 it is 0.15% a year, with a maximum of £375. Where your balance moves between bands during a quarter, Vanguard bases the fee on the average balance for that period.

Because the structures differ, no single figure says which is cheaper for you. Dealing costs, the funds you pick and your pot size all feed in. For each side's full list, see ii SIPP fees and Vanguard SIPP fees; pension charges explains the wider picture.

What sits outside the platform fee

On Vanguard's side, fund management costs are separate and come out of the fund price. Its self-managed costs and charges document (dated 20 August 2026) puts ongoing fund costs between 0.05% and 0.78%, varying by fund, as at 30 June 2026. If you choose Vanguard's managed option, the management fee for a Managed Personal Pension is 0.30% a year (Vanguard Managed Service costs and charges, dated 15 June 2026), on top of the account fee and fund costs. The self-managed route is covered in managed versus self-managed Vanguard.

On ii's side, each trade has its own charge under your plan, so how often you buy and sell matters. ii's sheet lists, for example, UK and US shares at £3.99 on Core and Plus and £2.99 on Premium. Its charges page adds that cash held earns interest, and Vanguard says it does not charge a service fee for holding cash but "will retain an amount of the interest received from the bank(s)" (Vanguard client terms, August 2026).

Shares and ETFs, or Vanguard funds only?

This is the clearest difference between the two. ii's SIPP page describes "over 1,000 Exchange-Traded Funds" alongside shares, funds, investment trusts and bonds and gilts, so a reader who wants individual shares or trusts in a pension finds that on ii. Vanguard's key features rule out, for now, holding anything other than Vanguard Funds; its transfer page refers to "over 85 funds". Someone who wants a low-effort route may find that narrower range a plus rather than a limit. Detail is in what an ii SIPP can hold and Vanguard SIPP funds. If you would rather not choose, compare ii's ready-made option with Vanguard's managed service above.

Drawdown, annuities and getting money out

Both take flexible income through drawdown. ii says the money in your drawdown pot "remains invested" and that you can set up regular withdrawals or lump sums. Vanguard says that when you move money into drawdown you choose from its full range of funds or one of four investment pathways, and that it sets no minimum withdrawal, so tax-free cash can come out in several smaller sums.

An annuity is bought elsewhere in both cases, as the table shows. Weigh drawdown against an annuity on drawdown providers, and read Vanguard drawdown and ii drawdown for the steps. Free, impartial guidance is available from Pension Wise.

Switching providers: how transfers compare

Neither charges to transfer in, though your existing provider might. Timings are each provider's own: ii says a pension transferred entirely as cash "usually takes 2 to 6 weeks", and investments moved as they are "typically" 8 to 12 weeks. Vanguard says "some pension transfers could take as little as 10 working days or as long as 10 weeks or more". Any non-Vanguard funds are sold by your existing provider and reach Vanguard as cash.

The rules for pensions already in drawdown differ. ii says a pension already in drawdown can only be transferred to it in full. Vanguard accepts pensions in flexible drawdown, but not capped drawdown, and its key features allow a partial transfer out of uncrystallised funds only if at least £10,000 remains. Before any move, check for guarantees you would lose. Moving to Vanguard and transfer fees cover the steps and costs. Worried that moving could cost a guarantee? An adviser can read your old plan's terms alongside you, and a request through the form here is how you arrange the call.

Who might lean towards which

A reader who wants shares, trusts or a wide ETF choice in the pension, and expects to trade often, may find ii's structure suits. A reader who wants a small set of Vanguard funds, or Vanguard's managed option, may find Vanguard's does. Which Vanguard band applies depends on everything you have invested with Vanguard, not the pension alone. Neither is a recommendation; see the Vanguard SIPP review, ii SIPP review and best SIPPs for the wider field.

Interactive Investor and Vanguard SIPP: questions readers ask

Can an ISA and a SIPP share one fee?

Both providers say so, in different ways. ii lets accounts in the same name, a SIPP and ISAs among them, sit under one plan and one monthly fee. Vanguard charges a single account fee across all your accounts with it, split according to the invested balance in each.

Can my employer pay into either?

ii says it is possible for employers to contribute through one-off or regular payments, once you have asked your employer. Vanguard's key features (November 2025) allow employer payments if the company is your own limited company and you are its director, it is incorporated and domiciled in the UK, and payments come directly from a company bank account you are authorised to use. Direct Debits from business accounts are not accepted, but one-off payments from a company debit card are. Paying into a Vanguard SIPP has the detail.

Is any of this advice?

No. These are the providers' published terms, not a recommendation. Choosing between ii, Vanguard or neither is personal to your pot and tax position, so an adviser's call-back, which you request with this page's form, may help.