AJ Bell vs Vanguard SIPP: AJ Bell charges by what you hold and each deal, Vanguard by invested balance, and Vanguard holds only its own funds.

Every figure here comes from AJ Bell or Vanguard and carries the date its document prints, if it prints one. Pension Wise gives free guidance on taking money out; MoneyHelper describes it as impartial and backed by government. Your pot decides how AJ Bell's rules and Vanguard's land. Fill the short form on this page in, and an FCA-authorised adviser can try them on it during a call-back that costs you nothing.

AJ Bell vs Vanguard SIPP: the differences in one table

PointAJ Bell SIPPVanguard Personal Pension (self-managed)
Account charge, funds0.25% on the first £250,000, 0.10% on the next £250,000 to £500,000, no charge over £500,000£4 a month while invested assets across all your Vanguard accounts (cash excluded) are under £32,000; 0.15% a year at and above £32,000, maximum £375 a year
Account charge, shares0.25%, maximum £10 per month; this charge also covers ETFs, investment trusts, gilts and bonds, which AJ Bell groups with sharesDirect shares cannot be held
DealingFunds £1.50; shares £5.00, or £3.50 after 10 or more share deals the previous month; regular monthly investing into selected investments freeETF trades normally placed at the next dealing point (10.15am or 2.10pm) free of brokerage; an ETF trade through the optional quote and deal service costs £7.50
Fund running costsEach fund has its own ongoing charges figureOngoing costs of 0.05% to 0.78% a year, varying by fund (as at 30 June 2026) and deducted from the fund's price; transaction costs, and a bid-offer spread on ETFs, are extra
What it holdsShares, funds, investment trusts, ETFs, bonds and giltsVanguard funds only
Paying inFrom £25 a month by Direct Debit (maximum £4,000 net) or £500 one-offAt least £500 as a first lump sum, or a £100 a month minimum
Employer paymentsAn employed member's employer can pay inNot a workplace pension, Vanguard says; even so, its key features (November 2025) let your own UK limited company pay in while you are its director, with the money sent from the company's bank account
AnnuityPurchase charge £150Not provided; transfers out to an annuity provider

Sources and dates: AJ Bell's charges page (shows no date; read 4 November 2026) and key features (print reference AJBYI/SIPP/G/20261019); Vanguard's costs and charges document (20 August 2026), fees page (no date shown; read 29 October 2026) and key features (November 2025). AJ Bell's annuity charge is from its access FAQ, read 26 October 2026.

How the two charge: holdings and deals, or a balance band

AJ Bell's account charge depends on what you hold. AJ Bell's own example is a £60,200 SIPP of £24,000 in shares, £36,000 in funds and £200 in cash, which it prices at £12.50 per month in account charges, adding that the real figure depends on month-end values. Dealing is separate and depends on how often you trade.

Vanguard's account fee depends on the invested balance of every account you hold with it added together, with cash left out. Where the balance moves between the levels in a quarter, Vanguard works the fee out on the average balance for the period. You pay one account fee even with more than one Vanguard account. Fund costs are on top at both firms, inside the fund. The detail sits in Vanguard's SIPP fees and in the AJ Bell SIPP review; pension charges explains the layers in general.

Your balance, any shares, how often you trade and your chosen funds all feed in. Whether AJ Bell's method or Vanguard's costs you less depends on all of that; an adviser can test each if you ask for a call by sending this page's form, free.

Fund choice: AJ Bell's range or Vanguard's own funds

AJ Bell lists over 4,000 funds and ETFs on its SIPP page, read 29 October 2026, and its key features add shares, investment trusts, bonds and gilts. It says its SIPP cannot invest directly in commercial or residential property. Vanguard's key features say it does "not presently permit direct shares or any investment other than Vanguard Funds"; its transfer page, read 3 November 2026, mentions a range of over 85 funds. Vanguard SIPP fund options and AJ Bell SIPP investments go through each range.

Both warn that investment values can fall as well as rise and you may get back less than you put in.

Drawdown and taking the money out

AJ Bell's key features describe flexi-access drawdown, and its access FAQ lists no charge for it or for pension lump sums. It asks you to keep at least £100 in the account once you access it. Its withdrawals page (17 September 2026) says taking drawdown income or a pension lump sum for the first time triggers the money purchase annual allowance, limiting contributions to £10,000 a year.

Vanguard says it charges no fee to start using your pension and sets no minimum withdrawal, so you can stagger the tax-free cash. Its flexible income page says withdrawals arrive within 10 working days, and warns that a taxable income triggers the money purchase annual allowance. Choosing CHAPS costs £25 a payment. Vanguard does not currently choose and manage investments for pensions in drawdown. For the mechanics see AJ Bell SIPP drawdown and Vanguard SIPP drawdown; how the choices fit together is in pension drawdown.

Moving a pension in, or out again

AJ Bell says it is free to transfer in, and that if you transfer out it will not charge exit fees. If your existing provider charges to leave, AJ Bell says it will cover exit fees up to £500 when your account value is £20,000 or more. Vanguard says it charges no fee for transfers, though your existing provider might, and it does not accept pensions in capped drawdown. The sign-up route at AJ Bell is in opening an AJ Bell SIPP; for Vanguard, see transferring a pension to its SIPP.

What the two have in common

Each is for UK residents, neither gives advice on choosing investments, and each stops taking contributions you pay yourself once you reach 75. AJ Bell says you can access your pension from 55 (57 from 6 April 2028); Vanguard says access is usually not possible before 55 ("57 from 2028"). Neither charges a withdrawal fee, though Vanguard charges for CHAPS payments.

Which may suit whom

AJ Bell may suit someone who wants shares, investment trusts or a wider fund list, who wants to start from £25 a month, or whose employer, rather than their own limited company, pays in. Vanguard may suit someone content with Vanguard funds only, with a larger balance where a £375 maximum on the account fee matters, or one who wants a managed option for a pension not yet in drawdown. AJ Bell has a Ready-made pension (compared here) and Vanguard's managed service quotes a 0.30% a year management rate beside an account fee and fund costs (15 June 2026). Wider comparisons are in best SIPP UK.

Neither method is right for everyone. If pot, tax and plans all matter, this page's form can book a free call-back so an adviser can look at them together.

Questions on the two SIPPs

Can my employer pay into both?

An employed AJ Bell member's employer can pay in. Vanguard describes its pension as not a workplace pension. Even so, its key features (November 2025) take payments from your own limited company when you direct it, it is incorporated and domiciled in the UK, and the money is sent from the company's bank account.

What happens to Vanguard's fee near £32,000?

Vanguard charges £4 a month while your invested assets across all its accounts total less than £32,000, and 0.15% a year from that level, capped at £375 a year. When the balance moves between levels in a quarter, it uses the average for that period.

Do I pay to transfer in or out?

Neither provider charges for transfers, and AJ Bell may cover your old provider's exit fees up to £500. Your old provider might still charge, so check with it first.

Can a relative pay into either SIPP for me?

AJ Bell says it cannot accept contributions from another person on your behalf, including a spouse. Vanguard can accept them from a person such as a relative who is an existing client of its personal investor service.