An ill health retirement appeal usually starts with your scheme's own dispute procedure, then The Pensions Ombudsman if you are still unhappy.
A refusal, or an award at a lower tier than you hoped for, is not always the last word. Each scheme sets its own appeal steps and deadlines, and some are short. Your income plans may have a hole after a refusal. To have an FCA-authorised adviser size up what your remaining pensions might pay, ask for that phone conversation, free of charge, using this page's form.
Can you appeal an ill health retirement decision?
In the public schemes covered here, yes. The Civil Service Pension Scheme's member hub says: "Yes, you can appeal against a decision not to grant you ill-health retirement, or a decision to only give you a lower tier pension." NHSBSA accepts appeals against a rejection, or against a Tier 1 award with no leave for reassessment within 3 years where you believe Tier 2 was due. Teachers' Pensions allows two appeals, and the Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) runs complaints about any decision through its dispute procedure.
Elsewhere, first find out whose decision it was. The Pensions Ombudsman says that "Usually, the decision is made by your employer or the trustees of the scheme", and the rules may require a medical expert's opinion first. Who decides in each public scheme, and what the doctors test, is set out on the ill health retirement assessment page.
How do the internal dispute stages and time limits work?
Occupational schemes "should offer a formal Internal Dispute Resolution Procedure (IDRP)", says the Ombudsman, normally in two stages: your complaint is investigated and answered, and if you disagree you appeal, which opens stage two. A few schemes have one stage, and some can skip to the second.
Two kinds of time limit matter. One is how long the scheme may take: The Pensions Regulator's code expects each stage to be decided within four months, with the outcome notified within 21 days of the decision, although longer is allowed where appropriate. A public sector scheme's own regulations apply instead if they set shorter periods. The other is how long you have to start, which your scheme's procedure sets out. The Ombudsman advises complaining in writing, saying it is a formal complaint, and stating what you want done to put it right.
Which route applies in the LGPS, NHS, teachers' and civil service schemes?
| Scheme | First step and your deadline | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| LGPS (England and Wales) | Complain to the deciding body's adjudicator inside six months of its decision | Ask your pension fund to reconsider |
| NHS (NHSBSA) | Stage 1 form, with any further medical evidence | Write for a second review within 6 months of the Stage 1 letter |
| Teachers' Pension Scheme | First appeal by letter, no time limit | Second appeal within six months of the first rejection letter |
| Civil service | Form APP1 to your employer within three months | Senior physician, then an independent Medical Appeal Board |
Scotland differs: SPPA runs its separate NHS and teachers' schemes, and in the Scottish LGPS you have six months from the Stage 1 letter to appeal to SPPA at Stage 2.
LGPS
The LGPS member website calls stage one a formal review by the adjudicator, who "may allow a longer period" than six months. At stage two your pension fund can name the adjudicators and may have a form; the tiers are in LGPS ill health retirement.
NHS
NHSBSA sets 40 working days for each of its two stages and says it will tell you if the second review will take longer. While you dispute a Tier 2 decision you can ask for Tier 1 benefits, and if you win, Tier 2 is backdated to the date payment first began. SPPA tells NHS Scotland members who disagree with its medical advisers' decision to ask for a review under its dispute procedure. NHS ill health retirement explains Tier 1 and Tier 2.
Teachers
Both appeals can challenge a rejection or the level awarded, and a different medical adviser looks at each. Teachers' Pensions warns that an appeal against the level reopens the whole case, so the award could even become a rejection. Teachers' ill health retirement has more.
Civil service
The scheme's guide describes three stages, though reaching the third "is not automatic". A physician reviews your case, a senior physician with no earlier involvement asks whether a reasonable case exists, and only if doubt remains does it go to an independent Medical Appeal Board. Where the Board upholds the lower tier, its assessment is final on the medical question; the separate IDR procedure covers how the process was run, not the medical decision. See civil service ill health retirement and police ill health retirement; for any other scheme, ask for its dispute procedure document.
Does new medical evidence help an appeal?
It depends on the scheme, so ask before commissioning a report. In the civil service scheme you can appeal with or without new evidence, but without it the case is unlikely to progress beyond stage two, and if the scheme's adviser asks for more, it is for the member to source, provide and pay for it. The guide wants evidence that is "comprehensive, current (within the last three months)".
Teachers' Pensions is stricter: usually you can only submit evidence that was available when you first applied, and results of tests or treatment since then need a fresh application, though the Medical Advisers have discretion. NHSBSA asks you to send any further evidence you want considered with the Stage 1 form.
Gathering fresh evidence can take months. Meanwhile an adviser the FCA has authorised can run through your income options with you by telephone, free, after you complete this page's call-back form.
When can The Pensions Ombudsman look at a refused ill health pension?
Usually only after you have finished the scheme's process, though it may step in earlier if the other party refuses to engage or takes longer than allowed without a reason, provided you show you tried to complete it. You generally have three years from the event, or from when you knew or should reasonably have known of it if that is later. It cannot take a complaint a court or employment tribunal is already considering.
It examines the decision-making, not the medicine: whether the decision-maker was the right person, followed and interpreted the scheme rules correctly, and weighed appropriate factors. In its words, "It is not our role to consider whether we would have reached the same decision", and it cannot question medical advice properly taken into account. If the process was wrong it can direct the decision to be retaken, but not require a pension to be paid: the result may stay the same. That is why your best evidence belongs at the scheme's own appeal stages. The Pensions Ombudsman explains the service itself.
Who helps for free if you challenge a refusal?
MoneyHelper is government-backed, and the Ombudsman gives its advice line, 0800 011 3797. The Ombudsman's service is "free to access and designed so that you do not need professional help", and if you hire a solicitor or claims firm anyway, "even if your complaint is upheld, you are unlikely to get any costs for professional advice repaid".
If you are too unwell to manage this, the Ombudsman lets a family member or friend act as your representative. The civil service scheme allows a relative, friend or trade union representative to appeal for you, with your consent, inside the three-month period, and to sit with you at the Medical Appeal Board. Unions and Citizens Advice are covered in free ill health retirement advice and free pension guidance.
More on challenging an ill health decision
Is an ill health retirement review the same as an appeal?
Not always. NHSBSA's "second review" is the second stage of an appeal, but SPPA also uses review for a later look at some NHS Scotland lower-tier awards, which may let you reapply for upper tier within three years.
Will I be paid while I appeal?
Not automatically. NHSBSA allows Tier 1 benefits while a Tier 2 decision is disputed, and the civil service guide says successful appeals are backdated if your service ended before the appeal finished.
How long does an appeal take?
Generally up to four months a stage, less where the scheme's regulations say so; how long ill health retirement takes has the timings.
Before you send your appeal
- Find your scheme's dispute procedure and note its deadline.
- Say in writing that it is a formal appeal and what outcome you want.
Whatever the appeal decides, your remaining pensions still need a plan, so request a free ring-back from an adviser employed by an FCA-authorised firm in the form here.
Sources: Civil Service Pension Scheme member hub and Medical reviews and appeals guide; NHSBSA; SPPA; Teachers' Pensions ill-health retirement guide (October 2025); LGPS member website; The Pensions Regulator, Dispute resolution procedures (general code in force 28 March 2024); The Pensions Ombudsman. All read in October and November 2026.