An ill health retirement assessment is a medical review of the evidence about your health, and who makes the final call depends on your scheme.

Who decides an ill health retirement application?

An employer or the scheme decides after a doctor's opinion, and the doctor's part differs between schemes. The NHS and teachers' schemes below are those for England and Wales; Scotland's are run by the Scottish Public Pensions Agency (SPPA).

Your HR team, scheme administrator or union can explain the test itself at no cost. Money worries about the gap between salary and an ill health pension are another matter; an FCA-authorised adviser rings about those, at no charge, after this page's form arrives.

NHS Pension Scheme

NHS Pensions' member ill health retirement guide (version V1A, read November 2026) puts the decision with the scheme's medical advisers: "The tier you receive will be decided by our medical advisors and will depend on the severity of your condition and how likely it is you may be able to work again." It describes them as doctors and advisers qualified in occupational health who give an independent assessment and "make a recommendation to us". Your employer ending your employment does not settle the question: the guide says that "does not automatically lead to payment of ill health retirement benefits". See ill health retirement in the NHS.

Teachers' Pension Scheme

Teachers' Pensions says medical advisers appointed by the Secretary of State consider the application and evidence, and "the final decision is made by us, taking into account the Medical Advisor observations". There is more in Teachers' Pension ill health retirement.

Civil Service pension (alpha)

In alpha, the Civil Service scheme's member guidance makes the Scheme Medical Adviser (SMA) the decision-maker on health: it must be satisfied, in its opinion, that your condition permanently stops you doing your job or any similar role. The SMA is "a third party organisation that is appointed by the Scheme Manager to provide independent medical advice", and it sends your employer a certificate saying whether you qualify and at which of two levels. More is in ill health retirement in the Civil Service.

Local Government Pension Scheme (England and Wales)

The decision belongs to your employer. The LGPS member website says: "Your employer must get the opinion of an independent occupational health physician appointed by them before it makes its decision." The regulations call that doctor an IRMP, an independent registered medical practitioner with an occupational health qualification, and require the employer to obtain the IRMP's certificate before deciding whether you qualify and for which tier. The IRMP must not have been involved in your case before. These are the England and Wales rules: the Scottish LGPS member website sets out Tier 1 and Tier 2 only, so in Scotland check with your fund. The wider picture is in ill health retirement in the LGPS.

What does the ill health retirement medical assessment test?

The test is a scheme's own wording about your work and your future capacity, not a general idea of being unwell.

In the LGPS (England and Wales) the regulations set two conditions: you are permanently incapable of efficiently doing the duties of your job, and you are not immediately capable of any gainful employment. The tiers then turn on how likely you are to manage gainful employment: Tier 1 if you are unlikely to before normal pension age, Tier 2 if unlikely within three years but likely before it, and Tier 3, a temporary pension, if you are likely to within three years or before normal pension age if that is sooner. The LGPS site defines gainful employment as paid employment for at least 30 hours a week for a year or more.

In the NHS scheme the two tiers are different in kind. Tier 1 needs you to be "permanently incapable of carrying out the duties of your own job". Tier 2 needs the Tier 1 condition plus being "permanently incapable of engaging in regular employment of like duration to your NHS job". In the guide, "permanently incapable" means until the scheme's normal pension age.

For career average members, the Teachers' Pension Scheme Regulations 2014 define a total incapacity condition: as well as being unfit for the employment the scheme covers despite appropriate medical treatment, your ability to carry out any work is "impaired by more than 90% and is likely to be impaired by more than 90% permanently". Teachers' Pensions' employer page ties the lower level to being permanently unable to teach while still able to work elsewhere, and the higher to being unable to do any gainful employment, for final salary and career average members alike.

For alpha, the Civil Service lower tier is paid if you are "permanently incapable of doing your own job or a similar role" and the upper tier if you are "permanently incapable of working in any kind of employment". Permanent means until your predicted State Pension age.

What the assessors ask about is partly set out too. The NHS guide lists what its advisers weigh, including treatment received so far, how your mind and body are working, and what rehabilitation would be reasonable. Police schemes have their own wording, covered in police ill health retirement; for any other scheme, ask its administrator for the rule, and the adviser reached through the form can explain what it means for your retirement income.

What medical evidence do assessors look at?

In the NHS scheme, part C of form AW33E is completed by your occupational health doctor, or where that is impossible by a GP or specialist. Deferred members use form AW240, with part 2 completed by the attending doctor, who may be a GP, hospital doctor or consultant. The advisers "can also request more medical evidence if they consider it relevant and helpful to their assessment, for example from your GP or specialist."

Teachers' Pensions asks for a medical report from a relevant consultant involved in your care, or a relevant treating clinician if there is no such consultant or they cannot provide one. It warns that its advisers "won't seek extra medical evidence and will recommend rejection of any application that is not supported by evidence clearly showing that the Ill-health Retirement criteria are met", and asks for evidence that is current, comprehensive and legible.

In alpha, the form asks you to allow the SMA to approach your doctor and other specialists, and your employer sends the SMA details of your job and sickness record. You "may be invited for an assessment by the SMA or asked to provide more details about your health."

Evidence can cost money. The NHS guide says occupational health can supply supporting information at no cost to active members with access to it, while a deferred member "will be responsible for any fee incurred". Teachers' Pensions says you or your employer will have to pay any fees.

What to prepare before you apply

  • Ask your employer or HR department for your scheme's ill health guide and application form, and which sections they complete and which you do.
  • Ask your GP, consultant or occupational health doctor who will write the report, how long it will take and whether they charge.
  • Check what the report must say against your scheme's wording: your own job, any employment, and "permanently".
  • Send a complete, signed form; the NHS guide warns an incomplete form may be returned, which will delay the application.
  • Keep copies of what you send. If the decision goes against you, the separate page on appealing an ill health retirement decision covers what comes next, and timings are in how long ill health retirement takes.

Free help is covered in free ill health retirement advice. An FCA-authorised adviser can weigh pensions, health and family at once, and you can ask for that through this page's short form.

Questions people ask about the assessment

Will I have to see a doctor in person?

It depends on the scheme. The alpha guidance says you may be invited to an assessment by the SMA or asked for more detail, while NHS advisers review the application and evidence.

Can being dismissed or getting sickness benefits secure ill health retirement?

Not in the NHS scheme. Its guide says an employer's decision to end your employment does not automatically lead to payment, and that receiving incapacity or disability benefits does not mean you will automatically receive ill health retirement benefits, because the criteria are different.

What if my evidence is not strong enough?

Teachers' Pensions says an application without enough evidence for a fully considered recommendation will not be accepted. Where it recommends rejection, the advisers give a rationale that may point to further evidence for an appeal or new application.

Does the same medical evidence count for benefits?

Do not assume so. The NHS guide says DWP uses different criteria, and benefits you can claim with ill health retirement covers that side.