Royal London pension vs Scottish Widows: Royal London sells through advisers, with a 1% basic charge on external funds; Scottish Widows sells direct.

The two firms sell pensions in different ways, so the comparison below keeps each firm's terms apart and declares no winner. Hold an older Royal London or Scottish Widows plan? Free of charge, one FCA-authorised adviser can phone you about it if this page's short form is filled in. Investments can fall as well as rise, so you may get back less than you paid in.

Royal London pension vs Scottish Widows pension: the differences side by side

Scottish Widows offers a SIPP (self-invested personal pension) as well as its Ready-Made Pension, so the table sets Royal London's personal pension against each.

Personal pension (Royal London)Ready-Made Pension (Scottish Widows)SIPP (Scottish Widows)
How you buy"We choose to distribute our personal pension products through financial advisers." advisers may charge, but should agree fees with you upfrontApply yourself if aged 18 to under 75 and resident in the UK for tax, then manage it in the appThe same age and residence condition; you place trades in the app
Main charge"The basic management charge for our external funds is 1% a year. An additional management charge applies to the majority of the external funds."0.3% a year administration account fee, charged each month and never under £5 a month0.25% a year of your investments' value, capped at £16.50 a month
Other charges namedThe fund leaflet says charges are regularly reviewed and could change in futureFund managers' ongoing charges 0.1%; their transaction costs up to 0.19%Online UK trades cost £5 each; international trades carry no charge but a 1.5% exchange rate applies
InvestmentsInternal funds managed by Royal London Asset Management, and funds run by external managersExperts place you in a portfolio matched to your chosen start yearYou choose and trade your own investments
Paying inThe amount and frequency are for you to setTo start: £120 or more monthly or one payment of £4,000 (before tax relief), or transfers totalling at least £10,000From £1, including transfers
Taking moneyNormally from 55 (57 from 6 April 2028); drawdown is called Income ReleaseFrom 55 (57 from 6 April 2028); no annuity optionFrom 55 (57 from 6 April 2028); no annuity option

Sources for Royal London: its personal pensions page (read 26 October 2026), fund range summary L5PD0005/02 (information correct as at April 2026) and manage-your-pension page (read 27 October 2026). For Scottish Widows: the compare page (read 26 October 2026), the Ready-Made Pension page (read 2 November 2026) and SIPP key features, print code WOMSIPP KFD 0007 (0726 IH), read 26 October 2026. Both firms say charges can change.

Why Royal London's 1% and Scottish Widows' 0.3% are different kinds of number

Royal London's 1% is the basic management charge for its external funds only. Its leaflet adds that an additional management charge applies to most of those funds. Separately, its personal pension page says advisers may charge, and should agree any fees with you upfront. So a Royal London plan's cost turns on the funds held and the adviser fee agreed. Each layer is in Royal London pension charges.

Scottish Widows' 0.3% and 0.25% are account charges, with fund and dealing costs listed beside them. Its SIPP key features say "Typically, ongoing charges could be between 0.25% to 1.5%, and transaction costs around 0.5%", depending on what you hold. Adding the lines up is a job for the figures on your own illustration; Scottish Widows pension fees and pension charges explained show how. Which of those layers would apply to a Royal London plan you are weighing is a point the adviser can answer free of charge when you submit the form.

ProfitShare and Scottish Widows' with-profits plans

Royal London says that "when we do well, we'll aim to boost your pension and stocks and shares ISA by adding a share of our profits to your plan each year", and that it "can't guarantee" an award every year. It reports £199 million shared with approximately 2.4 million eligible customers in April 2026. You are eligible if you took out a pension plan with Royal London since 1 July 2001; Crest Secure and Retirement Account contracts are excluded, as are any self-invested retirement savings and any plan that began with The Co-operative Insurance Society. In an occupational scheme, eligibility goes by the date the scheme began, not the date you joined. Awards are applied as at 1 April, and the plan has to be in force the previous 31 December as well as on the award date.

Scottish Widows' with-profits page is for people who already hold such a policy, and says the policy may have bonuses added to its guaranteed minimum benefits. Policyholders' money is pooled in part of its With Profits Fund. The two are described in different terms and apply to different plans, so neither tells you what the other would add to your pot. Royal London also lists a With Profits fund, "Not available if Income Release is being used". Whether a plan you already hold carries either feature is set out in that plan's own documents.

Workplace pensions from either firm: ask the scheme

Royal London has three types of workplace pension, and your employer can tell you which one you are in; charges, it adds, can vary with your scheme and investments. Scottish Widows' Master Trust lets employers choose a different default investment option for their section, and its trustees report charges for each default and alternative fund. For charges on a workplace plan, ask your employer, the scheme or the trustees, using your statement. Where an adviser can help is a different question: whether to move or combine an old pot, covered in Royal London pension transfer and Scottish Widows pension transfer.

Taking money out: ages, annuities and the allowance that follows

Neither firm departs from the normal minimum pension age: 55 today, 57 from 6 April 2028. Annuities differ. Scottish Widows says its Ready-Made Pension and SIPP "don’t offer an annuity option, but we can help you find a provider that does". Royal London's cash lump sum page says the rest of your savings can be used for a flexible income or to buy a regular secure income paid for the rest of your life.

Each firm words the contribution limit that follows taxable withdrawals in its own way. Royal London says: "If you take out more than 25% of your pension, you may restrict what you can pay into your pensions to £10,000 a year." Scottish Widows says: "But when you take taxable money from your pension, it will trigger a limit on how much you can contribute to all your pensions. This is called the Money Purchase Annual Allowance." It adds: "This means that there would be a tax charge if you contributed more than £10,000 to your pensions in a year." The allowance itself is explained in the money purchase annual allowance. Free, impartial guidance on your options is available from Pension Wise.

Which suits whom: Royal London or Scottish Widows

A Royal London personal pension may suit someone who wants an adviser involved from the start, since that is how the firm sells it, and who values a mutual's ProfitShare while accepting it is not guaranteed. It may not suit someone who wants to open a plan alone online; Royal London pension without an adviser covers that.

Scottish Widows' Ready-Made Pension may fit a saver happy to hand investment choices to experts, starting at £120 a month. Its own page says it may not be right for anyone who wants "choice or control over how your pension is invested", pointing to the SIPP. The SIPP may suit someone comfortable choosing and trading their own investments, with the dealing costs above. Other pairings are in Aviva vs Royal London, Aviva vs Scottish Widows and PensionBee vs Scottish Widows; each firm has its own review at is Royal London pension good and is Scottish Widows pension good. Weighing the two for a real pot? Once the form is in, an adviser rings and can lay both firms' papers beside your own position.

Moving a pension between Royal London and Scottish Widows, and other questions

Can I move a pension from Royal London to Scottish Widows?

Scottish Widows says pensions moving in must come from a UK-based provider and not already be in drawdown, and warns against losing valuable features or guarantees. A Ready-Made Pension opened by transfer needs at least £10,000 of transfers. How Royal London handles a pension leaving is in its transfer page.

Who provides these pensions?

Royal London's fund leaflet names The Royal London Mutual Insurance Society Limited, Financial Services Register number 117672. Scottish Widows' Ready-Made Pension and SIPP are provided by Embark Investment Services Limited, which the key features give as register number 737356.

Will Scottish Widows take money from my own limited company?

Its compare page says "If you're a director of a limited company, you can also pay company contributions." For the SIPP, the same page says employer contributions are accepted from a limited company where you are the business owner or one of the directors.