Vanguard vs Hargreaves Lansdown SIPP: Vanguard’s pension holds only Vanguard funds, with an account fee that tops out at £375 a year, while HL offers thousands of investments and a fund charge that starts at 0.35% a year and steps down on larger holdings.

The Vanguard SIPP is sold as the Vanguard Personal Pension; Hargreaves Lansdown is shortened to HL here. Neither wins outright, because the cheaper or better-fitting account depends on your pot, your investments and how often you trade. Vanguard’s bands and HL’s tiers only mean something against your pensions. Running both over your holdings suits an FCA-authorised adviser, reachable from the form on this page.

Vanguard SIPP vs HL SIPP: the published facts side by side

Web pages show the date they were read; documents show the date printed on them. Investments can go down as well as up, so the amount you get back could be lower than what you paid in.

PointVanguard Personal PensionHL SIPP
Account charge on funds£4 a month (£48 a year) while all your Vanguard accounts together hold under £32,000 invested, cash excluded; from £32,000, 0.15% a year, at most £375 a year. (Vanguard costs and charges document dated 20 August 2026; £48 from the Vanguard fees page, read 29 October 2026)Value of funds, tiered: up to £250,000, 0.35%; £250,000 to £1mn, 0.25%; £1mn to £2mn, 0.10%; over £2mn, no charge. (HL SIPP charges page, read 29 October 2026)
Account charge on shares, ETFs and similarNone: direct shares are not held (see the next row).0.35%, capped at £12.50 per month, on shares, ETFs, investment trusts, bonds, gilts and VCTs. (HL charges page, read 29 October 2026)
What you can holdVanguard mutual funds and ETFs only: the Key Features say direct shares, and anything other than Vanguard Funds, are not at present allowed in the pension. (Key Features, printed date November 2025)“thousands of investment options” or the HL Ready-Made Pension Plan. (HL SIPP charges page, read 29 October 2026)
Fund-level costsEach fund’s ongoing costs: 0.05% to 0.78% a year (figures as at 30 June 2026), taken from the fund price; transaction costs come on top. (Vanguard self-managed costs and charges document, 20 August 2026)Some investments have their own charges set by the fund manager. HL says it negotiates discounts for more than 500 funds. (HL charges page, read 29 October 2026)
DealingNo fund entry or exit charge and no charge for switching funds (Vanguard fees page, read 29 October 2026). Each ETF trade through Quote and Deal, an optional service, costs a fixed £7.50; Vanguard waives it on ETF batch dealing, run twice a day (Vanguard costs and charges document, 20 August 2026).One-off fund trades £1.95. Share trades £6.95 (0 to 19 trades last month) or £3.95 (20 or more). Monthly Direct Debit investing: no charge. Phone or post: £29 per trade. (HL charges page, read 29 October 2026)
To startFirst lump sum at least £500, or at least £100 a month; both are before tax relief. (Key Features, November 2025)HL says “No minimum amount to open your SIPP”, and an FAQ on the same HL page says “from as little as £25 a month, or by making a one-off contribution of £100 or more.” (HL SIPP page, read 26 October 2026)
Who can open oneOpen to applicants 18 or over who reside and pay tax in the UK; not available to US persons; it stops accepting contributions once you reach 75. (Key Features, November 2025)HL lists three conditions: between 18 and 75 years old, a UK resident, and a UK taxpayer (HL adds: to benefit from tax relief). (HL SIPP page, read 26 October 2026)
CashAccount fee not charged on cash; cash earns interest at a managed rate. (Vanguard fees page, read 29 October 2026; Key Features, November 2025)Free to hold uninvested cash, which earns interest. (HL charges page, read 29 October 2026)

Fund and trading costs sit on top of each provider’s account charge. For each provider’s full list, see Vanguard SIPP fees and Hargreaves Lansdown SIPP fees.

Why the two charges are hard to line up

Vanguard’s account fee is a flat £48 a year at first, then a percentage that stops rising at £375 a year. HL’s is a percentage that steps down on larger fund holdings, with a monthly cap on shares. One provider quotes a fee on the whole invested balance across your Vanguard accounts, the other assesses each HL account separately. HL’s charges page gives the example of £200,000 in funds in an HL SIPP and another £200,000 in an HL Fund and Share Account: each sits in the 0.35% tier, not the combined total. Vanguard says “You only pay 1 account fee even if you have more than one account.”

A fair total for either account needs your fund choices, how often you trade and whether you hold shares, which only you can supply. An adviser can test your actual holdings against both fee structures, without charge, on the call-back the form here arranges. The wider picture is in pension charges and fees.

What each lets you hold

This is the clearest difference. Vanguard’s Key Features describe a range of its own mutual funds and ETFs, index and actively managed, and its transfer page mentions “our range of over 85 funds”. HL describes funds, shares, ETFs and more, plus a managed Ready-Made Pension Plan. Vanguard also offers a ready-made retirement fund and a managed service in which it chooses the investments, and says you cannot buy or sell funds yourself under the managed service.

So someone who wants one fund manager’s tracker funds fits Vanguard’s range, while someone who wants individual company shares has to look at HL, because the Vanguard document above says direct shares are not permitted. More on Vanguard’s range is in Vanguard SIPP fund options, and on SIPP holdings in general in what a SIPP can invest in.

Transfers in and drawing an income

On transfers in the two are alike on cost. Vanguard says “We do not charge a fee for transfers. Although your existing provider might, so you should check with them first.” (Vanguard transfer page, read 3 November 2026). HL says it is free to transfer, with no set-up cost from its side, and that your current provider may apply an exit fee. (HL transfer page, read 26 October 2026). Timing and conditions differ:

  • Vanguard: it says some transfers take as little as 10 working days and others 10 weeks or more, and it cannot accept a pension in capped drawdown. (Vanguard transfer page, read 3 November 2026)
  • HL: a partial transfer may be possible, although not every provider offers one. (HL transfer page, read 26 October 2026)

When you take money out, Vanguard’s transfer page (read 3 November 2026) says it does not charge a fee when you begin using your pension savings. It adds that it has no minimum withdrawal amount and that, once you tell it you are happy to proceed, you receive the withdrawal within 10 working days. (Vanguard drawdown page, read 26 October 2026). HL’s drawdown page says “Take income your way, with no withdrawal fees”, and it is free to set up drawdown and to adjust the income. (HL drawdown pages, read 26 October 2026). Money left invested keeps its charges in both. Step-by-step pages: transferring to Vanguard, paying into an HL SIPP, Vanguard drawdown and HL withdrawals. How tax-free cash and income work is in pension drawdown explained, and Pension Wise offers free government-backed guidance.

Questions people ask about the two SIPPs

Which SIPP is cheaper, Vanguard or Hargreaves Lansdown?

It turns on your pot and what is in it, so no single answer holds. Vanguard’s fee is capped at £375 a year in account fees, while HL’s charge on funds steps down above £250,000, and both providers also have fund costs and trading costs of their own.

Is there a charge for leaving either one?

Vanguard lists no charge for transferring out or closing your account (fees page, read 29 October 2026). HL says “No, you won’t be charged any exit fees if you leave or transfer out of our platform.” (charges page, read 29 October 2026). A receiving provider may have its own terms.

Do both offer a ready-made option?

Yes. HL offers its Ready-Made Pension Plan as an option within the HL SIPP. Vanguard lists a ready-made retirement fund and a managed service. Reviews of each are in Vanguard SIPP review and is the HL SIPP good.

Vanguard or HL: who each may suit

These are things to weigh, not a recommendation. A Vanguard SIPP may suit someone who is content with Vanguard’s own funds and prefers a flat fee while the pot is small. An HL SIPP may suit someone after individual shares, investment trusts or funds from many managers, or who wants to start with a small monthly amount. Someone with a large fund-only pot may find the cap on one and the tiers on the other change the picture. How Vanguard and HL apply to your retirement is a talk to have with an FCA-authorised adviser, booked by putting your name in the enquiry form here. For other providers, see the best SIPPs in the UK.