Legal & General pension vs Scottish Widows: L&G's Personal Pension has a 0.25% service charge; Scottish Widows' SIPP 0.25% (capped) and its Ready-Made Pension 0.30%.
Comparing a Legal & General pension vs Scottish Widows means weighing three products, because Scottish Widows sells two personal pensions and L&G one. Phoning an FCA-authorised adviser about an old L&G or Scottish Widows pension costs nothing; to arrange it, leave your details in our call-back form on this page. Investments can fall as well as rise, so you may get back less than you paid in.
Three pensions, two firms: what you can open yourself
L&G's Personal Pension is, according to its key features (April 2026 on the cover), a fully online plan for customers aged 18 to 74. You choose a default option, five diversified funds matched to how much risk you want, or one fund from a longer list.
Scottish Widows has two. The Ready-Made Pension invests for you, in a portfolio built around the year you want to start taking money. The SIPP (self-invested personal pension) suits people who pick and trade their own investments. Both are managed in the Scottish Widows app, and applicants must be 18 or over, under 75 and UK-resident for tax.
Neither firm sells these as a replacement for an employer's scheme. L&G's product page says a personal pension "should not be considered as a replacement for a workplace pension, if you have access to one", and Scottish Widows says the same of its two.
Legal & General vs Scottish Widows pension charges and funds
Each cell is the firm's own figure, with the document it comes from; charges change, so check the latest version before deciding.
| L&G Personal Pension | Scottish Widows: Ready-Made | Scottish Widows: SIPP | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main charge | 0.25% a year service charge on your Pension's value, worked out daily and taken monthly (key features, April 2026) | An account fee of 0.30% a year, taken monthly, with a minimum of £5 a month (RMP KFD 0004 (0226 IH)) | 0.25% a year administration charge, with a £16.50 monthly cap (£198 a year) (WOMSIPP KFD 0007 (0726 IH)) |
| Fund charges | Vary from fund to fund, the key features say; their example is a 0.31% charge on the Multi-Index 3 Fund (as at May 2024). The product page (read 2 November 2026) also quotes a 0.31% Fund Management Charge | The page lists 0.1% for ongoing investment fund charges plus fund transaction costs of up to 0.19% (compare page, read 6 November 2026) | "Typically, ongoing charges could be between 0.25% to 1.5%, and transaction costs around 0.5%", depending on the fund (WOMSIPP KFD 0007 (0726 IH)) |
| Investing | Default option, five risk-based funds, or a single fund chosen by you (product page, 2 November 2026) | Scottish Widows' experts choose and gradually lower the risk as your start year nears (compare page, 6 November 2026) | Shares, funds, ETFs, investment trusts, bonds and gilts, plus a managed, packaged "Start-Up" fund (WOMSIPP KFD 0007 (0726 IH)) |
| To start | £100 first payment, then £1; transfers from £1 (key features, April 2026) | £120 a month, £4,000 in one go, or £10,000 in transfers (compare page, 6 November 2026) | From £1, transfers included (compare page, 6 November 2026) |
| Taking money | No charge for withdrawing money from the Pension (key features, April 2026) | No extra charge for accessing retirement benefits or for transfers in or out (RMP KFD 0004 (0226 IH)) | No extra charge for accessing benefits in flexi-access drawdown or for transfers in or away (WOMSIPP KFD 0007 (0726 IH)) |
The two 0.25% figures are measured differently. L&G's is a percentage of your Pension's value, taken from uninvested cash or by selling units. The SIPP charge is worked out on investments held on the last business day of each month, leaves out uninvested cash and stops at the cap; online trades in UK shares add £5 each, with discounts possible. Fuller breakdowns are in Legal & General pension fees, Scottish Widows pension fees and pension charges; fund ranges are in which Legal & General pension fund and Scottish Widows pension funds.
Paying in: employers, company directors and old pensions
L&G states that "Your employer won’t be able to contribute to this Pension as it isn’t suitable to meet automatic enrolment obligations". Its product page goes further, naming "You have a limited company and want to contribute from your business" as a sign the plan may not be right for you. The Scottish Widows Ready-Made Pension also refuses employer money, but its SIPP accepts contributions from a limited company's business account where "you must be the limited company business owner or one of the directors and receive authorisation from any other majority business shareholder(s)".
Transfers in follow separate lists. L&G says it cannot take control of your existing investments, so the old provider sells them first, and the plans it names as ones it can't consolidate include "final salary" schemes, With Profits plans and plans carrying guaranteed annuity rates or guaranteed minimum benefits. The Ready-Made Pension takes cash transfers only and refuses safeguarded benefits, defined benefit schemes, pensions in drawdown and part-transfers. The SIPP also refuses safeguarded benefits and pensions in drawdown, and its key features describe in-specie transfers of investments as something that can take a few weeks. Steps and costs: Scottish Widows pension transfer and pension transfer fees.
Taking money out: tax-free cash, drawdown and the MPAA
Two limits stand out in the drawdown section of L&G's key features. On tax-free cash: "If you don’t take the full 25% when you set up your plan, our product doesn’t currently allow you to take the tax-free allowance later." On moving money in and paying more: "we can only accept full pension transfers into drawdown", and "You will not be able to make additional contributions." The Scottish Widows SIPP key features instead refer to taking "one or more" tax-free lump sums.
The money purchase annual allowance (MPAA) limits tax-relieved pension saving after you start flexible withdrawals, and both firms give £10,000 as the limit. They word the trigger differently. L&G: "If you haven’t flexibly accessed any of your existing pension benefits your first income payment from this plan will trigger the MPAA", while tax-free cash or an annuity does not. Scottish Widows' Ready-Made Pension key features say "taking taxable benefits (such as UFPLS or upon your first income withdrawal from your flexi-drawdown) will trigger the Money Purchase Annual Allowance (MPAA)", and its website adds that taking only tax-free cash will not affect future contributions. Practical steps are in pension drawdown and L&G pension withdrawal; Pension Wise offers free guidance before you choose.
If an employer chose your scheme
In a workplace scheme your employer picks the provider. L&G's Group Stakeholder key features (W13785, June 2026) describe the main charge as "something we agreed with your employer", and that the 0.75% automatic-enrolment cap "only applies to the default investment option". Scottish Widows' member page points you to your employer for contributions, eligibility and how to join, and its Master Trust trustees must report charges and transaction costs on every fund option members can select. See workplace pension charges.
Who each firm pitches its plans at
On L&G's page the Personal Pension is pitched at the self-employed, people wanting flexibility or consolidation, and anyone content with a short fund menu. It lists as poorer fits a reader whose workplace pension already meets their goals and anyone wanting many funds, specific shares or property funds. Scottish Widows aims the Ready-Made Pension at customers who do not want to make investment decisions themselves and the SIPP at those who do; the SIPP does not offer direct property, unquoted shares or gold bullion. Other pairings: L&G vs Royal London and Royal London vs Scottish Widows. Each firm against Aviva: Aviva vs L&G and Aviva vs Scottish Widows. Single-firm views: is an L&G pension good and is a Scottish Widows pension good.
To move an old workplace pot into either personal pension, talk it through first: this page's call-back form sets up a call with an adviser holding FCA authorisation, at no cost.
Legal & General or Scottish Widows: your questions
Can I top up my L&G plan after I start taking an income?
Not once that plan is in drawdown, its key features say; they suggest opening a second Personal Pension if you want to keep paying in.
Is the Scottish Widows SIPP the same product as the Ready-Made Pension?
No. They are separate pensions with different charges, start-up amounts and investment control, as the table shows.
Is there a cooling-off period at each firm?
Yes. L&G lets you cancel within 30 days of the Pension opening, and the Scottish Widows key features refer to a 30 day cancellation period. You could get back less than you paid in if markets have fallen.
Which of the two suits my own pots?
That turns on your pots, how hands-on you want to be and whether an old plan holds guarantees. Weighing those is a job for an FCA-regulated adviser, who calls back without charge when you fill in our call-back form on this page.