AJ Bell vs PensionBee comes down to who chooses the investments: you, inside AJ Bell’s SIPP, or PensionBee’s ready-made plans for one annual fee.
They are built for different savers, so what follows sets each firm’s own terms side by side rather than naming a winner. Submitting the form on this page sets you up with a no-charge talk with an FCA-authorised adviser, a way to test a SIPP you run yourself against PensionBee’s plans using what you actually hold.
AJ Bell vs PensionBee: who chooses what the money is invested in?
In an AJ Bell SIPP you do. Its key features say you commit to take responsibility for deciding how the SIPP is invested, and that one aim is to let you “manage your portfolio yourself”. The SIPP page lists shares, funds, ETFs, bonds and gilts, with AJ Bell’s own funds among the choices inside the SIPP. Its separate Ready-made pension is a different account, and AJ Bell says “You can only open one type of pension account with us.” That choice is covered in AJ Bell SIPP vs Ready-made pension.
PensionBee answers differently. Asked in its FAQ whether it is a SIPP, it says it offers “a personal pension that allows you to select your own investment plan from our range of diverse and curated plans”. Its fees page lists six: Global Leaders, 4Plus, Tracker, Climate, Shariah and Preserve. New customers go into Global Leaders if under 50 and 4Plus at 50 or over, and PensionBee says you can change plan at any time. What each plan holds is in which PensionBee plan is best, and SIPPs in general in what a SIPP is.
AJ Bell and PensionBee charges side by side
Read dates, as neither page shows its own: AJ Bell’s SIPP charges page 6 November 2026; PensionBee’s fees page and FAQ 4 November 2026.
| Charge | AJ Bell SIPP | PensionBee |
|---|---|---|
| Yearly charge | Funds: 0.25% on the first £250,000, 0.10% on the next £250,000, nothing over £500,000. Shares: 0.25% (max £10 per month) | From 0.50% to 0.95% by plan, halved on any savings above £100,000 |
| Buying and selling | Funds £1.50 a deal; shares £5.00, falling to £3.50 when last month saw at least 10 share deals; free monthly investing into selected investments | No platform, fund or trading fee on top of the one fee, with the exceptions below |
| Costs each firm names outside its main charge | Each fund has its own ongoing charges figure (OCF) | Transaction costs, which PensionBee says are separate from the annual fee |
| Moving a pension in | “it’s FREE to transfer in” | No fee to transfer pensions to PensionBee |
| Starting income | No withdrawal fee for drawdown | Drawdown is free except in two cases, below |
| Leaving | No exit fees | No exit fee at any point; the annual fee runs only up to the date the request completes (how to transfer out) |
On its fees page PensionBee says there is “one fee that covers everything including transferring your pensions, switching plans, contributing to or withdrawing from your pension”. The asterisk on that line leads only to the £150 withdrawal fee, and PensionBee names other costs that sit outside its annual fee:
- Full withdrawal fee: drawdown is free, PensionBee says, “unless you withdraw everything within 12 months of having a live balance with us or the balance of your account is less than £150 at the point of withdrawal”, when a £150 fee applies. Its figures include VAT where applicable.
- Transaction costs: they arise when the money manager buys or sells investments in your plan and sit outside the annual fee.
- Switching plans: there is no switching fee, but small costs called an “anti-dilution levy” apply to switches, PensionBee says, as at other providers.
PensionBee has a fee calculator and AJ Bell a charges calculator for your own figures. PensionBee’s full grid is on PensionBee fees, with the general picture in pension charges and fees.
Bringing an old pension across: cash, exit fees and tracing
Both say they charge nothing to receive a transfer, but the mechanics differ. PensionBee “can only accept cash transfers”, so old investments are sold first, and it says the average transfer takes 12 weeks (see how long PensionBee takes). AJ Bell says you choose whether to move investments as they are or sell and move cash, and notes that selling means sitting in cash, out of the market, until the move finishes. Transferring into an AJ Bell SIPP goes through what can come across.
- Old exit fees. AJ Bell will “pay up to £35 per investment moved and up to £100 for general exit fees”, to “an overall maximum of £500 per person”. The SIPP, ISA or Dealing account being transferred must be worth £20,000 or more, and you claim by sending AJ Bell copies of documents proving the transfer costs you paid your old provider, by email or post. PensionBee will seek your go-ahead before finishing a transfer when the old scheme’s exit fee tops £10, or when the pension comes with special benefits or guarantees.
- Finding lost pots. AJ Bell’s Pension finder is “exclusively available to AJ Bell customers”. PensionBee says it cannot trace old pensions for you and points to the government’s Pension Tracing Service; see can PensionBee find my pensions.
- Guarantees. PensionBee’s FAQ says a pension with guaranteed benefits over £30,000, a final salary promise for example, needs advice from an FCA-regulated independent financial adviser before the move, and PensionBee wants evidence that a Pension Transfer Specialist gave or checked positive advice. The legal test is a transfer value of safeguarded benefits above £30,000 (Pension Schemes Act 2015 s48; SI 2015/742 regulation 5).
Taking money out, and the £10,000 allowance
Both give 55 as the earliest age (57 from 2028) and both describe up to 25% tax-free with the rest staying invested. AJ Bell says the tax-free amount is subject to the overall lump sum allowance of £268,275, and that once you start taking money you must keep at least £100 in the account. PensionBee offers one-off or automatic monthly withdrawals from any plan, with one-off payments typically taking 7 to 10 working days, and an annuity through its partner, Legal & General. Steps are in AJ Bell SIPP drawdown and how to withdraw from PensionBee.
On the reduced allowance, AJ Bell’s page dated 17 September 2026 says: “When you first take drawdown income or a pension lump sum, you’ll trigger something called the money purchase annual allowance (MPAA).” That cuts the annual allowance for defined contribution pensions to £10,000 a year, with a tax charge if you go over it across those schemes. AJ Bell adds that moving into drawdown sets it off only with the first income payment. The MPAA explained sets out the rule itself. Anyone planning to keep contributing after a first withdrawal can raise the lower allowance with an adviser on the free call the form books.
The same AJ Bell page calls Pension Wise “a free, impartial government service”; what Pension Wise is explains what it offers.
Who each one may suit
An AJ Bell SIPP may suit someone who wants to pick and manage their own shares, funds or bonds, and accepts that AJ Bell says “we aren’t authorised to give advice to help you choose your investments”. It may also interest someone moving an account worth £20,000 or more with exit fees the offer above might meet, within its conditions, or someone whose employer wants to pay in, which AJ Bell’s key features allow. It may not suit someone who would rather not decide what to hold.
A PensionBee plan may suit someone who prefers one annual fee and a short list of plans, and is happy to move old pensions across as cash. PensionBee also gives each customer a UK-based account manager. It may not suit someone who wants individual shares, or existing investments moved across as they are. Nor will it suit someone needing an employer scheme: PensionBee says it does not offer a workplace pension, so it cannot be used for auto-enrolment (see PensionBee for employers). A firm closer to PensionBee on format is compared in PensionBee vs Moneybox.
Cost and advice: two smaller questions
Which one is cheaper?
That depends on pot size, the mix of funds and shares, how often you trade and which PensionBee plan applies, so neither firm’s page can say it for you; an adviser can run your own figures.
Does either firm advise me which to pick?
Not according to their own pages. AJ Bell’s key features answer “No” to whether it can help you choose investments, and PensionBee describes itself as offering no financial advice or recommendations. See AJ Bell SIPP advice and PensionBee financial advice.
Before you act on any figure here
Values can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you paid in. Both firms can change their charges, so read each live page before you decide. The sums turn on your own pots, so a sensible last step is having an FCA-authorised adviser weigh the two firms for you; leave your details in the form for a free ring-back.